What are some Chinese sources testifying the extreme weather events of 535-536 CE?












6















The Wikipedia page Extreme weather events of 535–536 lists under "Documentary evidence" that:





  • Low temperatures, even snow during the summer (snow reportedly fell in August in China during the Northern and Southern dynasties, which
    caused the harvest there to be delayed

  • "A dense, dry fog" in the Middle East, China and Europe




The page does provide a reference (Ochoa, George; Jennifer Hoffman; Tina Tin (2005). Climate: The Force That Shapes Our World and the Future of Life on Earth. Emmaus, PA: Rodale. p. 71.), but upon reading the referenced book, I noticed that the original quote was itself unsubstantiated, as shown in the picture I took below (at the end of the book there was only a Further Reading list):



enter image description here



I then proceeded to find other academic sources online. One article titled Spatial Response to Major Volcanic Events in or about AD 536, 934 and 1258 includes a passage quite similar to that found on the Wikipedia page, except slight variation in time:




The above results for Mongolia are consistent with the observations of
summer frosts and snow, crop failure, decreased star visibility and
famine documented for northern China in July and August of AD 536–7.




it listed the following citation for that passage:




Pang, K. and Chou, H.-H.: 1985, Unpublished research, in S. Weisbard,
‘Excavating Words: A Geological Tool’, Science News 127, 91–94.




So I went to this cited article, which contains the following:




The effect of this volcano was also felt in China. Pang reports that,
during the spring and fall equinoxes each year, the ancient Chinese
looked for Canopus -the brightest star in the constellation of Alpha
Carina-to assure themselves of good times ahead and to demark the
seasons. In A.D. 536, however, Canopus was not seen. Pang found
records from the state of Ching in southern China reporting frost and
snow in July and August that killed the seedling crop, causing a major
famine the following autumn. The accounts also show that the effects
of the eruption were noted until 538. Other kingdoms reported similar
disasters; one record indicated that the weather was so severe that 70
to 80 percent of the people starved to death
, says Pang.




Unfortuantely, the article does not provide any specific references to this quote, and it seems that Pang's research was indeed unpublished.



I have just begun to look into the massive amount of Chinese chronicles from this period with the hope of finding the exact entries quoted by Pang, in particular the highlighted quote concerning the severity of the disaster, which seems like to be highly exaggerated. In the meantime, I would really appreciate if someone could point me to a specific passage from an ancient Chinese source that confirms aforementioned descriptions.



Thank you.










share|improve this question

























  • Your Wikipedia link is broken.

    – Carey Gregory
    3 hours ago











  • Thanks for noting. Just fixed it.

    – mooncatcher
    3 hours ago
















6















The Wikipedia page Extreme weather events of 535–536 lists under "Documentary evidence" that:





  • Low temperatures, even snow during the summer (snow reportedly fell in August in China during the Northern and Southern dynasties, which
    caused the harvest there to be delayed

  • "A dense, dry fog" in the Middle East, China and Europe




The page does provide a reference (Ochoa, George; Jennifer Hoffman; Tina Tin (2005). Climate: The Force That Shapes Our World and the Future of Life on Earth. Emmaus, PA: Rodale. p. 71.), but upon reading the referenced book, I noticed that the original quote was itself unsubstantiated, as shown in the picture I took below (at the end of the book there was only a Further Reading list):



enter image description here



I then proceeded to find other academic sources online. One article titled Spatial Response to Major Volcanic Events in or about AD 536, 934 and 1258 includes a passage quite similar to that found on the Wikipedia page, except slight variation in time:




The above results for Mongolia are consistent with the observations of
summer frosts and snow, crop failure, decreased star visibility and
famine documented for northern China in July and August of AD 536–7.




it listed the following citation for that passage:




Pang, K. and Chou, H.-H.: 1985, Unpublished research, in S. Weisbard,
‘Excavating Words: A Geological Tool’, Science News 127, 91–94.




So I went to this cited article, which contains the following:




The effect of this volcano was also felt in China. Pang reports that,
during the spring and fall equinoxes each year, the ancient Chinese
looked for Canopus -the brightest star in the constellation of Alpha
Carina-to assure themselves of good times ahead and to demark the
seasons. In A.D. 536, however, Canopus was not seen. Pang found
records from the state of Ching in southern China reporting frost and
snow in July and August that killed the seedling crop, causing a major
famine the following autumn. The accounts also show that the effects
of the eruption were noted until 538. Other kingdoms reported similar
disasters; one record indicated that the weather was so severe that 70
to 80 percent of the people starved to death
, says Pang.




Unfortuantely, the article does not provide any specific references to this quote, and it seems that Pang's research was indeed unpublished.



I have just begun to look into the massive amount of Chinese chronicles from this period with the hope of finding the exact entries quoted by Pang, in particular the highlighted quote concerning the severity of the disaster, which seems like to be highly exaggerated. In the meantime, I would really appreciate if someone could point me to a specific passage from an ancient Chinese source that confirms aforementioned descriptions.



Thank you.










share|improve this question

























  • Your Wikipedia link is broken.

    – Carey Gregory
    3 hours ago











  • Thanks for noting. Just fixed it.

    – mooncatcher
    3 hours ago














6












6








6


1






The Wikipedia page Extreme weather events of 535–536 lists under "Documentary evidence" that:





  • Low temperatures, even snow during the summer (snow reportedly fell in August in China during the Northern and Southern dynasties, which
    caused the harvest there to be delayed

  • "A dense, dry fog" in the Middle East, China and Europe




The page does provide a reference (Ochoa, George; Jennifer Hoffman; Tina Tin (2005). Climate: The Force That Shapes Our World and the Future of Life on Earth. Emmaus, PA: Rodale. p. 71.), but upon reading the referenced book, I noticed that the original quote was itself unsubstantiated, as shown in the picture I took below (at the end of the book there was only a Further Reading list):



enter image description here



I then proceeded to find other academic sources online. One article titled Spatial Response to Major Volcanic Events in or about AD 536, 934 and 1258 includes a passage quite similar to that found on the Wikipedia page, except slight variation in time:




The above results for Mongolia are consistent with the observations of
summer frosts and snow, crop failure, decreased star visibility and
famine documented for northern China in July and August of AD 536–7.




it listed the following citation for that passage:




Pang, K. and Chou, H.-H.: 1985, Unpublished research, in S. Weisbard,
‘Excavating Words: A Geological Tool’, Science News 127, 91–94.




So I went to this cited article, which contains the following:




The effect of this volcano was also felt in China. Pang reports that,
during the spring and fall equinoxes each year, the ancient Chinese
looked for Canopus -the brightest star in the constellation of Alpha
Carina-to assure themselves of good times ahead and to demark the
seasons. In A.D. 536, however, Canopus was not seen. Pang found
records from the state of Ching in southern China reporting frost and
snow in July and August that killed the seedling crop, causing a major
famine the following autumn. The accounts also show that the effects
of the eruption were noted until 538. Other kingdoms reported similar
disasters; one record indicated that the weather was so severe that 70
to 80 percent of the people starved to death
, says Pang.




Unfortuantely, the article does not provide any specific references to this quote, and it seems that Pang's research was indeed unpublished.



I have just begun to look into the massive amount of Chinese chronicles from this period with the hope of finding the exact entries quoted by Pang, in particular the highlighted quote concerning the severity of the disaster, which seems like to be highly exaggerated. In the meantime, I would really appreciate if someone could point me to a specific passage from an ancient Chinese source that confirms aforementioned descriptions.



Thank you.










share|improve this question
















The Wikipedia page Extreme weather events of 535–536 lists under "Documentary evidence" that:





  • Low temperatures, even snow during the summer (snow reportedly fell in August in China during the Northern and Southern dynasties, which
    caused the harvest there to be delayed

  • "A dense, dry fog" in the Middle East, China and Europe




The page does provide a reference (Ochoa, George; Jennifer Hoffman; Tina Tin (2005). Climate: The Force That Shapes Our World and the Future of Life on Earth. Emmaus, PA: Rodale. p. 71.), but upon reading the referenced book, I noticed that the original quote was itself unsubstantiated, as shown in the picture I took below (at the end of the book there was only a Further Reading list):



enter image description here



I then proceeded to find other academic sources online. One article titled Spatial Response to Major Volcanic Events in or about AD 536, 934 and 1258 includes a passage quite similar to that found on the Wikipedia page, except slight variation in time:




The above results for Mongolia are consistent with the observations of
summer frosts and snow, crop failure, decreased star visibility and
famine documented for northern China in July and August of AD 536–7.




it listed the following citation for that passage:




Pang, K. and Chou, H.-H.: 1985, Unpublished research, in S. Weisbard,
‘Excavating Words: A Geological Tool’, Science News 127, 91–94.




So I went to this cited article, which contains the following:




The effect of this volcano was also felt in China. Pang reports that,
during the spring and fall equinoxes each year, the ancient Chinese
looked for Canopus -the brightest star in the constellation of Alpha
Carina-to assure themselves of good times ahead and to demark the
seasons. In A.D. 536, however, Canopus was not seen. Pang found
records from the state of Ching in southern China reporting frost and
snow in July and August that killed the seedling crop, causing a major
famine the following autumn. The accounts also show that the effects
of the eruption were noted until 538. Other kingdoms reported similar
disasters; one record indicated that the weather was so severe that 70
to 80 percent of the people starved to death
, says Pang.




Unfortuantely, the article does not provide any specific references to this quote, and it seems that Pang's research was indeed unpublished.



I have just begun to look into the massive amount of Chinese chronicles from this period with the hope of finding the exact entries quoted by Pang, in particular the highlighted quote concerning the severity of the disaster, which seems like to be highly exaggerated. In the meantime, I would really appreciate if someone could point me to a specific passage from an ancient Chinese source that confirms aforementioned descriptions.



Thank you.







medieval-china reference climate






share|improve this question















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited 3 hours ago







mooncatcher

















asked 5 hours ago









mooncatchermooncatcher

39012




39012













  • Your Wikipedia link is broken.

    – Carey Gregory
    3 hours ago











  • Thanks for noting. Just fixed it.

    – mooncatcher
    3 hours ago



















  • Your Wikipedia link is broken.

    – Carey Gregory
    3 hours ago











  • Thanks for noting. Just fixed it.

    – mooncatcher
    3 hours ago

















Your Wikipedia link is broken.

– Carey Gregory
3 hours ago





Your Wikipedia link is broken.

– Carey Gregory
3 hours ago













Thanks for noting. Just fixed it.

– mooncatcher
3 hours ago





Thanks for noting. Just fixed it.

– mooncatcher
3 hours ago










2 Answers
2






active

oldest

votes


















4














The chronicles Beishi "History of the North" and Nanshi "History of the South" have at least some of what you are looking for.





The Nanshi chronicle mentions frost and snow. This is cited in Catastrophe: An Investigation into the Origins of the Modern World by David Keys:




In July 537 China was hit by frost, while in August it snowed. The
History of the Southern Dynasties recorded that “in July in Qingzhou
and [another province] there was a fall of frost”
and that “in August
in Qingzhou there was snow,”
which “ruined the crops.”




The Nanshi chronicle is also cited in the The Palgrave Handbook of Climate History:




the early seventh-century Nanshi chronicle refers to “yellow dust”
that “fell like snow” in 536 and 537. In the latter year, it “filled
scoops when picked up.” The dust was almost certainly Gobi sand (not
volcanic ash), but this signals that 536 and 537 were unusually dry.






Keys also has the following paragraph which cites the Beishi:




“Because of drought, there was an imperial edict which ordered that in
the capital [Ch’ang-an], in all provinces, commanderies and districts,
one should bury the corpses,” says the Bei shi for late April to early
May 535.1 “[There was] great drought. [The government] had to provide
water at the city gates [of Ch’ang-an] and the hall gates [of the
palace] as well as the gates of the government offices,” says the
entry for late June and early July of the same year. Then in September
536, in the north Chinese “provinces of Bian, Si, Zhuo and Jian, hail
fell” and there was “a great famine.” By December the situation had
deteriorated to such an extent that the government had to send special
inspectors “to investigate [the conditions of] the famished refugees
who were roaming around north of the Yellow River.”




The next paragraph then adds:




And in Shaanxi province, “the land within the Passes,” The Annals of
the Western Wei in the Bei shi
state that there was “a great famine,”
and that “the people practiced cannibalism and 70 to 80 percent of the
population died.







share|improve this answer


























  • As far as I investigated too, Nanshi records the quote Lars is citing.

    – Kentaro Tomono
    1 hour ago











  • Beishi, would have been "Wei Shi". ( I don't know which is correct, but it would be according to how to pronounce Chinese 魏 "Wei" ( like Bei? ) dynasty. )

    – Kentaro Tomono
    13 mins ago





















1














This is the supplementary answer to that of Lars Bosteen.



As he said, according to this site( Japanese ), Nanshi records multiple quite unusual events occurred in Lyan Dynasty ( English ).



Quote ( from the above Japanese source )




534年閏12月丙午、西南方で雷鳴が二度、響いた。




>In the intercalary December, 534AD, we heard the lightening sound twice at South West. ( Nanshi 1.7.4.1 )




これは先にも引用した火山噴火への言及だが、恐らく梁の人々はこのようなことはすぐ忘れてしまっただろう。不可思議なことと言ってもやはり、庶民には何の関係もない・・・筈だった。しかしそれから異常なことが次々と起こった。翌535年の冬十月、雪のような黄塵が降った1。これが火山灰だったか気候の大異変に起因する季節はずれの砂嵐だったかは今となっては確かめる術もない。この黄塵は翌536年11月2、537年2月1日3、550年1月丁巳の日4にも観測された。



This would be the reference to the volcano explosion of the Krakatoa, in Indonesia, that occurred in 535 AD, though I assume people in Lyan Dynasty would've forgotten such lightenings soon from their memories. So those, the unusual lightening sounds, seemed.., should have been nothing to do with the living of people. But parallels of extraordinary climate events occurred multiple time since the sound. In the next year, in October, yellow dusts amounted like snow ( Nanshi 1.7.4.1 ). We have no clue now to confirm that this was the dust of the result of the volcano explosion that happened in the previous year. But these dusts are recorded in Nanshi, observed in the next year, in November 536 ( Nanshi 1.7.4.2 ), on the first of February 537, ( Nanshi 1.7.4.3 ), on 4th of January in 550 ( Nanshi, 1.7.6.4 ).







何かがおかしい。梁の民もそう思い始めたことだろう。しかし時既に遅し、大異変の歯車は回り始めていた。537年の夏は異常な冷夏に見舞われ、6月、青州の胊山で霜害が発生し[5]、さらに秋7月、青州で雪が降り、穀物収穫に被害を及ぼした[6]。青州といえば、現在の山東半島の北緯37°の場点にあり、日本のいわき市、北米のカリフォルニア、中東のシリアなどと同緯度に当たる。茨城県で8月に雪が降るようなものである。




Gradually updated due to the enormous difficulties of the translation.



Conclusion



Nanshi, the chronicle of events of the Lyan Dynasty, records multiple events of unusual climate events that occurred from the 534AD to 550AD, as also the 北史 ( I am sorry I can not translate ), the chronicle of events of the Northern Wei Dynasty records the same very unusual climate events which occurred around the same period that were recorded by Nanshi.






share|improve this answer

























    Your Answer








    StackExchange.ready(function() {
    var channelOptions = {
    tags: "".split(" "),
    id: "324"
    };
    initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

    StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
    // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
    if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
    StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
    createEditor();
    });
    }
    else {
    createEditor();
    }
    });

    function createEditor() {
    StackExchange.prepareEditor({
    heartbeatType: 'answer',
    autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
    convertImagesToLinks: false,
    noModals: true,
    showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
    reputationToPostImages: null,
    bindNavPrevention: true,
    postfix: "",
    imageUploader: {
    brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
    contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
    allowUrls: true
    },
    noCode: true, onDemand: true,
    discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
    ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
    });


    }
    });














    draft saved

    draft discarded


















    StackExchange.ready(
    function () {
    StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fhistory.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f51147%2fwhat-are-some-chinese-sources-testifying-the-extreme-weather-events-of-535-536-c%23new-answer', 'question_page');
    }
    );

    Post as a guest















    Required, but never shown

























    2 Answers
    2






    active

    oldest

    votes








    2 Answers
    2






    active

    oldest

    votes









    active

    oldest

    votes






    active

    oldest

    votes









    4














    The chronicles Beishi "History of the North" and Nanshi "History of the South" have at least some of what you are looking for.





    The Nanshi chronicle mentions frost and snow. This is cited in Catastrophe: An Investigation into the Origins of the Modern World by David Keys:




    In July 537 China was hit by frost, while in August it snowed. The
    History of the Southern Dynasties recorded that “in July in Qingzhou
    and [another province] there was a fall of frost”
    and that “in August
    in Qingzhou there was snow,”
    which “ruined the crops.”




    The Nanshi chronicle is also cited in the The Palgrave Handbook of Climate History:




    the early seventh-century Nanshi chronicle refers to “yellow dust”
    that “fell like snow” in 536 and 537. In the latter year, it “filled
    scoops when picked up.” The dust was almost certainly Gobi sand (not
    volcanic ash), but this signals that 536 and 537 were unusually dry.






    Keys also has the following paragraph which cites the Beishi:




    “Because of drought, there was an imperial edict which ordered that in
    the capital [Ch’ang-an], in all provinces, commanderies and districts,
    one should bury the corpses,” says the Bei shi for late April to early
    May 535.1 “[There was] great drought. [The government] had to provide
    water at the city gates [of Ch’ang-an] and the hall gates [of the
    palace] as well as the gates of the government offices,” says the
    entry for late June and early July of the same year. Then in September
    536, in the north Chinese “provinces of Bian, Si, Zhuo and Jian, hail
    fell” and there was “a great famine.” By December the situation had
    deteriorated to such an extent that the government had to send special
    inspectors “to investigate [the conditions of] the famished refugees
    who were roaming around north of the Yellow River.”




    The next paragraph then adds:




    And in Shaanxi province, “the land within the Passes,” The Annals of
    the Western Wei in the Bei shi
    state that there was “a great famine,”
    and that “the people practiced cannibalism and 70 to 80 percent of the
    population died.







    share|improve this answer


























    • As far as I investigated too, Nanshi records the quote Lars is citing.

      – Kentaro Tomono
      1 hour ago











    • Beishi, would have been "Wei Shi". ( I don't know which is correct, but it would be according to how to pronounce Chinese 魏 "Wei" ( like Bei? ) dynasty. )

      – Kentaro Tomono
      13 mins ago


















    4














    The chronicles Beishi "History of the North" and Nanshi "History of the South" have at least some of what you are looking for.





    The Nanshi chronicle mentions frost and snow. This is cited in Catastrophe: An Investigation into the Origins of the Modern World by David Keys:




    In July 537 China was hit by frost, while in August it snowed. The
    History of the Southern Dynasties recorded that “in July in Qingzhou
    and [another province] there was a fall of frost”
    and that “in August
    in Qingzhou there was snow,”
    which “ruined the crops.”




    The Nanshi chronicle is also cited in the The Palgrave Handbook of Climate History:




    the early seventh-century Nanshi chronicle refers to “yellow dust”
    that “fell like snow” in 536 and 537. In the latter year, it “filled
    scoops when picked up.” The dust was almost certainly Gobi sand (not
    volcanic ash), but this signals that 536 and 537 were unusually dry.






    Keys also has the following paragraph which cites the Beishi:




    “Because of drought, there was an imperial edict which ordered that in
    the capital [Ch’ang-an], in all provinces, commanderies and districts,
    one should bury the corpses,” says the Bei shi for late April to early
    May 535.1 “[There was] great drought. [The government] had to provide
    water at the city gates [of Ch’ang-an] and the hall gates [of the
    palace] as well as the gates of the government offices,” says the
    entry for late June and early July of the same year. Then in September
    536, in the north Chinese “provinces of Bian, Si, Zhuo and Jian, hail
    fell” and there was “a great famine.” By December the situation had
    deteriorated to such an extent that the government had to send special
    inspectors “to investigate [the conditions of] the famished refugees
    who were roaming around north of the Yellow River.”




    The next paragraph then adds:




    And in Shaanxi province, “the land within the Passes,” The Annals of
    the Western Wei in the Bei shi
    state that there was “a great famine,”
    and that “the people practiced cannibalism and 70 to 80 percent of the
    population died.







    share|improve this answer


























    • As far as I investigated too, Nanshi records the quote Lars is citing.

      – Kentaro Tomono
      1 hour ago











    • Beishi, would have been "Wei Shi". ( I don't know which is correct, but it would be according to how to pronounce Chinese 魏 "Wei" ( like Bei? ) dynasty. )

      – Kentaro Tomono
      13 mins ago
















    4












    4








    4







    The chronicles Beishi "History of the North" and Nanshi "History of the South" have at least some of what you are looking for.





    The Nanshi chronicle mentions frost and snow. This is cited in Catastrophe: An Investigation into the Origins of the Modern World by David Keys:




    In July 537 China was hit by frost, while in August it snowed. The
    History of the Southern Dynasties recorded that “in July in Qingzhou
    and [another province] there was a fall of frost”
    and that “in August
    in Qingzhou there was snow,”
    which “ruined the crops.”




    The Nanshi chronicle is also cited in the The Palgrave Handbook of Climate History:




    the early seventh-century Nanshi chronicle refers to “yellow dust”
    that “fell like snow” in 536 and 537. In the latter year, it “filled
    scoops when picked up.” The dust was almost certainly Gobi sand (not
    volcanic ash), but this signals that 536 and 537 were unusually dry.






    Keys also has the following paragraph which cites the Beishi:




    “Because of drought, there was an imperial edict which ordered that in
    the capital [Ch’ang-an], in all provinces, commanderies and districts,
    one should bury the corpses,” says the Bei shi for late April to early
    May 535.1 “[There was] great drought. [The government] had to provide
    water at the city gates [of Ch’ang-an] and the hall gates [of the
    palace] as well as the gates of the government offices,” says the
    entry for late June and early July of the same year. Then in September
    536, in the north Chinese “provinces of Bian, Si, Zhuo and Jian, hail
    fell” and there was “a great famine.” By December the situation had
    deteriorated to such an extent that the government had to send special
    inspectors “to investigate [the conditions of] the famished refugees
    who were roaming around north of the Yellow River.”




    The next paragraph then adds:




    And in Shaanxi province, “the land within the Passes,” The Annals of
    the Western Wei in the Bei shi
    state that there was “a great famine,”
    and that “the people practiced cannibalism and 70 to 80 percent of the
    population died.







    share|improve this answer















    The chronicles Beishi "History of the North" and Nanshi "History of the South" have at least some of what you are looking for.





    The Nanshi chronicle mentions frost and snow. This is cited in Catastrophe: An Investigation into the Origins of the Modern World by David Keys:




    In July 537 China was hit by frost, while in August it snowed. The
    History of the Southern Dynasties recorded that “in July in Qingzhou
    and [another province] there was a fall of frost”
    and that “in August
    in Qingzhou there was snow,”
    which “ruined the crops.”




    The Nanshi chronicle is also cited in the The Palgrave Handbook of Climate History:




    the early seventh-century Nanshi chronicle refers to “yellow dust”
    that “fell like snow” in 536 and 537. In the latter year, it “filled
    scoops when picked up.” The dust was almost certainly Gobi sand (not
    volcanic ash), but this signals that 536 and 537 were unusually dry.






    Keys also has the following paragraph which cites the Beishi:




    “Because of drought, there was an imperial edict which ordered that in
    the capital [Ch’ang-an], in all provinces, commanderies and districts,
    one should bury the corpses,” says the Bei shi for late April to early
    May 535.1 “[There was] great drought. [The government] had to provide
    water at the city gates [of Ch’ang-an] and the hall gates [of the
    palace] as well as the gates of the government offices,” says the
    entry for late June and early July of the same year. Then in September
    536, in the north Chinese “provinces of Bian, Si, Zhuo and Jian, hail
    fell” and there was “a great famine.” By December the situation had
    deteriorated to such an extent that the government had to send special
    inspectors “to investigate [the conditions of] the famished refugees
    who were roaming around north of the Yellow River.”




    The next paragraph then adds:




    And in Shaanxi province, “the land within the Passes,” The Annals of
    the Western Wei in the Bei shi
    state that there was “a great famine,”
    and that “the people practiced cannibalism and 70 to 80 percent of the
    population died.








    share|improve this answer














    share|improve this answer



    share|improve this answer








    edited 3 hours ago

























    answered 4 hours ago









    Lars BosteenLars Bosteen

    39.5k8185250




    39.5k8185250













    • As far as I investigated too, Nanshi records the quote Lars is citing.

      – Kentaro Tomono
      1 hour ago











    • Beishi, would have been "Wei Shi". ( I don't know which is correct, but it would be according to how to pronounce Chinese 魏 "Wei" ( like Bei? ) dynasty. )

      – Kentaro Tomono
      13 mins ago





















    • As far as I investigated too, Nanshi records the quote Lars is citing.

      – Kentaro Tomono
      1 hour ago











    • Beishi, would have been "Wei Shi". ( I don't know which is correct, but it would be according to how to pronounce Chinese 魏 "Wei" ( like Bei? ) dynasty. )

      – Kentaro Tomono
      13 mins ago



















    As far as I investigated too, Nanshi records the quote Lars is citing.

    – Kentaro Tomono
    1 hour ago





    As far as I investigated too, Nanshi records the quote Lars is citing.

    – Kentaro Tomono
    1 hour ago













    Beishi, would have been "Wei Shi". ( I don't know which is correct, but it would be according to how to pronounce Chinese 魏 "Wei" ( like Bei? ) dynasty. )

    – Kentaro Tomono
    13 mins ago







    Beishi, would have been "Wei Shi". ( I don't know which is correct, but it would be according to how to pronounce Chinese 魏 "Wei" ( like Bei? ) dynasty. )

    – Kentaro Tomono
    13 mins ago













    1














    This is the supplementary answer to that of Lars Bosteen.



    As he said, according to this site( Japanese ), Nanshi records multiple quite unusual events occurred in Lyan Dynasty ( English ).



    Quote ( from the above Japanese source )




    534年閏12月丙午、西南方で雷鳴が二度、響いた。




    >In the intercalary December, 534AD, we heard the lightening sound twice at South West. ( Nanshi 1.7.4.1 )




    これは先にも引用した火山噴火への言及だが、恐らく梁の人々はこのようなことはすぐ忘れてしまっただろう。不可思議なことと言ってもやはり、庶民には何の関係もない・・・筈だった。しかしそれから異常なことが次々と起こった。翌535年の冬十月、雪のような黄塵が降った1。これが火山灰だったか気候の大異変に起因する季節はずれの砂嵐だったかは今となっては確かめる術もない。この黄塵は翌536年11月2、537年2月1日3、550年1月丁巳の日4にも観測された。



    This would be the reference to the volcano explosion of the Krakatoa, in Indonesia, that occurred in 535 AD, though I assume people in Lyan Dynasty would've forgotten such lightenings soon from their memories. So those, the unusual lightening sounds, seemed.., should have been nothing to do with the living of people. But parallels of extraordinary climate events occurred multiple time since the sound. In the next year, in October, yellow dusts amounted like snow ( Nanshi 1.7.4.1 ). We have no clue now to confirm that this was the dust of the result of the volcano explosion that happened in the previous year. But these dusts are recorded in Nanshi, observed in the next year, in November 536 ( Nanshi 1.7.4.2 ), on the first of February 537, ( Nanshi 1.7.4.3 ), on 4th of January in 550 ( Nanshi, 1.7.6.4 ).







    何かがおかしい。梁の民もそう思い始めたことだろう。しかし時既に遅し、大異変の歯車は回り始めていた。537年の夏は異常な冷夏に見舞われ、6月、青州の胊山で霜害が発生し[5]、さらに秋7月、青州で雪が降り、穀物収穫に被害を及ぼした[6]。青州といえば、現在の山東半島の北緯37°の場点にあり、日本のいわき市、北米のカリフォルニア、中東のシリアなどと同緯度に当たる。茨城県で8月に雪が降るようなものである。




    Gradually updated due to the enormous difficulties of the translation.



    Conclusion



    Nanshi, the chronicle of events of the Lyan Dynasty, records multiple events of unusual climate events that occurred from the 534AD to 550AD, as also the 北史 ( I am sorry I can not translate ), the chronicle of events of the Northern Wei Dynasty records the same very unusual climate events which occurred around the same period that were recorded by Nanshi.






    share|improve this answer






























      1














      This is the supplementary answer to that of Lars Bosteen.



      As he said, according to this site( Japanese ), Nanshi records multiple quite unusual events occurred in Lyan Dynasty ( English ).



      Quote ( from the above Japanese source )




      534年閏12月丙午、西南方で雷鳴が二度、響いた。




      >In the intercalary December, 534AD, we heard the lightening sound twice at South West. ( Nanshi 1.7.4.1 )




      これは先にも引用した火山噴火への言及だが、恐らく梁の人々はこのようなことはすぐ忘れてしまっただろう。不可思議なことと言ってもやはり、庶民には何の関係もない・・・筈だった。しかしそれから異常なことが次々と起こった。翌535年の冬十月、雪のような黄塵が降った1。これが火山灰だったか気候の大異変に起因する季節はずれの砂嵐だったかは今となっては確かめる術もない。この黄塵は翌536年11月2、537年2月1日3、550年1月丁巳の日4にも観測された。



      This would be the reference to the volcano explosion of the Krakatoa, in Indonesia, that occurred in 535 AD, though I assume people in Lyan Dynasty would've forgotten such lightenings soon from their memories. So those, the unusual lightening sounds, seemed.., should have been nothing to do with the living of people. But parallels of extraordinary climate events occurred multiple time since the sound. In the next year, in October, yellow dusts amounted like snow ( Nanshi 1.7.4.1 ). We have no clue now to confirm that this was the dust of the result of the volcano explosion that happened in the previous year. But these dusts are recorded in Nanshi, observed in the next year, in November 536 ( Nanshi 1.7.4.2 ), on the first of February 537, ( Nanshi 1.7.4.3 ), on 4th of January in 550 ( Nanshi, 1.7.6.4 ).







      何かがおかしい。梁の民もそう思い始めたことだろう。しかし時既に遅し、大異変の歯車は回り始めていた。537年の夏は異常な冷夏に見舞われ、6月、青州の胊山で霜害が発生し[5]、さらに秋7月、青州で雪が降り、穀物収穫に被害を及ぼした[6]。青州といえば、現在の山東半島の北緯37°の場点にあり、日本のいわき市、北米のカリフォルニア、中東のシリアなどと同緯度に当たる。茨城県で8月に雪が降るようなものである。




      Gradually updated due to the enormous difficulties of the translation.



      Conclusion



      Nanshi, the chronicle of events of the Lyan Dynasty, records multiple events of unusual climate events that occurred from the 534AD to 550AD, as also the 北史 ( I am sorry I can not translate ), the chronicle of events of the Northern Wei Dynasty records the same very unusual climate events which occurred around the same period that were recorded by Nanshi.






      share|improve this answer




























        1












        1








        1







        This is the supplementary answer to that of Lars Bosteen.



        As he said, according to this site( Japanese ), Nanshi records multiple quite unusual events occurred in Lyan Dynasty ( English ).



        Quote ( from the above Japanese source )




        534年閏12月丙午、西南方で雷鳴が二度、響いた。




        >In the intercalary December, 534AD, we heard the lightening sound twice at South West. ( Nanshi 1.7.4.1 )




        これは先にも引用した火山噴火への言及だが、恐らく梁の人々はこのようなことはすぐ忘れてしまっただろう。不可思議なことと言ってもやはり、庶民には何の関係もない・・・筈だった。しかしそれから異常なことが次々と起こった。翌535年の冬十月、雪のような黄塵が降った1。これが火山灰だったか気候の大異変に起因する季節はずれの砂嵐だったかは今となっては確かめる術もない。この黄塵は翌536年11月2、537年2月1日3、550年1月丁巳の日4にも観測された。



        This would be the reference to the volcano explosion of the Krakatoa, in Indonesia, that occurred in 535 AD, though I assume people in Lyan Dynasty would've forgotten such lightenings soon from their memories. So those, the unusual lightening sounds, seemed.., should have been nothing to do with the living of people. But parallels of extraordinary climate events occurred multiple time since the sound. In the next year, in October, yellow dusts amounted like snow ( Nanshi 1.7.4.1 ). We have no clue now to confirm that this was the dust of the result of the volcano explosion that happened in the previous year. But these dusts are recorded in Nanshi, observed in the next year, in November 536 ( Nanshi 1.7.4.2 ), on the first of February 537, ( Nanshi 1.7.4.3 ), on 4th of January in 550 ( Nanshi, 1.7.6.4 ).







        何かがおかしい。梁の民もそう思い始めたことだろう。しかし時既に遅し、大異変の歯車は回り始めていた。537年の夏は異常な冷夏に見舞われ、6月、青州の胊山で霜害が発生し[5]、さらに秋7月、青州で雪が降り、穀物収穫に被害を及ぼした[6]。青州といえば、現在の山東半島の北緯37°の場点にあり、日本のいわき市、北米のカリフォルニア、中東のシリアなどと同緯度に当たる。茨城県で8月に雪が降るようなものである。




        Gradually updated due to the enormous difficulties of the translation.



        Conclusion



        Nanshi, the chronicle of events of the Lyan Dynasty, records multiple events of unusual climate events that occurred from the 534AD to 550AD, as also the 北史 ( I am sorry I can not translate ), the chronicle of events of the Northern Wei Dynasty records the same very unusual climate events which occurred around the same period that were recorded by Nanshi.






        share|improve this answer















        This is the supplementary answer to that of Lars Bosteen.



        As he said, according to this site( Japanese ), Nanshi records multiple quite unusual events occurred in Lyan Dynasty ( English ).



        Quote ( from the above Japanese source )




        534年閏12月丙午、西南方で雷鳴が二度、響いた。




        >In the intercalary December, 534AD, we heard the lightening sound twice at South West. ( Nanshi 1.7.4.1 )




        これは先にも引用した火山噴火への言及だが、恐らく梁の人々はこのようなことはすぐ忘れてしまっただろう。不可思議なことと言ってもやはり、庶民には何の関係もない・・・筈だった。しかしそれから異常なことが次々と起こった。翌535年の冬十月、雪のような黄塵が降った1。これが火山灰だったか気候の大異変に起因する季節はずれの砂嵐だったかは今となっては確かめる術もない。この黄塵は翌536年11月2、537年2月1日3、550年1月丁巳の日4にも観測された。



        This would be the reference to the volcano explosion of the Krakatoa, in Indonesia, that occurred in 535 AD, though I assume people in Lyan Dynasty would've forgotten such lightenings soon from their memories. So those, the unusual lightening sounds, seemed.., should have been nothing to do with the living of people. But parallels of extraordinary climate events occurred multiple time since the sound. In the next year, in October, yellow dusts amounted like snow ( Nanshi 1.7.4.1 ). We have no clue now to confirm that this was the dust of the result of the volcano explosion that happened in the previous year. But these dusts are recorded in Nanshi, observed in the next year, in November 536 ( Nanshi 1.7.4.2 ), on the first of February 537, ( Nanshi 1.7.4.3 ), on 4th of January in 550 ( Nanshi, 1.7.6.4 ).







        何かがおかしい。梁の民もそう思い始めたことだろう。しかし時既に遅し、大異変の歯車は回り始めていた。537年の夏は異常な冷夏に見舞われ、6月、青州の胊山で霜害が発生し[5]、さらに秋7月、青州で雪が降り、穀物収穫に被害を及ぼした[6]。青州といえば、現在の山東半島の北緯37°の場点にあり、日本のいわき市、北米のカリフォルニア、中東のシリアなどと同緯度に当たる。茨城県で8月に雪が降るようなものである。




        Gradually updated due to the enormous difficulties of the translation.



        Conclusion



        Nanshi, the chronicle of events of the Lyan Dynasty, records multiple events of unusual climate events that occurred from the 534AD to 550AD, as also the 北史 ( I am sorry I can not translate ), the chronicle of events of the Northern Wei Dynasty records the same very unusual climate events which occurred around the same period that were recorded by Nanshi.







        share|improve this answer














        share|improve this answer



        share|improve this answer








        edited 19 mins ago

























        answered 58 mins ago









        Kentaro TomonoKentaro Tomono

        699310




        699310






























            draft saved

            draft discarded




















































            Thanks for contributing an answer to History Stack Exchange!


            • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

            But avoid



            • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

            • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


            To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




            draft saved


            draft discarded














            StackExchange.ready(
            function () {
            StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fhistory.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f51147%2fwhat-are-some-chinese-sources-testifying-the-extreme-weather-events-of-535-536-c%23new-answer', 'question_page');
            }
            );

            Post as a guest















            Required, but never shown





















































            Required, but never shown














            Required, but never shown












            Required, but never shown







            Required, but never shown

































            Required, but never shown














            Required, but never shown












            Required, but never shown







            Required, but never shown







            Popular posts from this blog

            How did Captain America manage to do this?

            迪纳利

            南乌拉尔铁路局