Can a Knock spell open the door to Mordenkainen's Magnificent Mansion?












17












$begingroup$


Assuming that a Mordenkainen's Magnificent Mansion is conjured and the entrance is closed, could a creature make use of the Knock spell to open the door to the mansion?



Would the gateway be not considered as an object that Knock can interact with?



Would the creatures get immediately expelled even if the entrance is open (since they were not designated to be allowed inside the mansion at the time of casting)?










share|improve this question











$endgroup$

















    17












    $begingroup$


    Assuming that a Mordenkainen's Magnificent Mansion is conjured and the entrance is closed, could a creature make use of the Knock spell to open the door to the mansion?



    Would the gateway be not considered as an object that Knock can interact with?



    Would the creatures get immediately expelled even if the entrance is open (since they were not designated to be allowed inside the mansion at the time of casting)?










    share|improve this question











    $endgroup$















      17












      17








      17


      1



      $begingroup$


      Assuming that a Mordenkainen's Magnificent Mansion is conjured and the entrance is closed, could a creature make use of the Knock spell to open the door to the mansion?



      Would the gateway be not considered as an object that Knock can interact with?



      Would the creatures get immediately expelled even if the entrance is open (since they were not designated to be allowed inside the mansion at the time of casting)?










      share|improve this question











      $endgroup$




      Assuming that a Mordenkainen's Magnificent Mansion is conjured and the entrance is closed, could a creature make use of the Knock spell to open the door to the mansion?



      Would the gateway be not considered as an object that Knock can interact with?



      Would the creatures get immediately expelled even if the entrance is open (since they were not designated to be allowed inside the mansion at the time of casting)?







      dnd-5e spells






      share|improve this question















      share|improve this question













      share|improve this question




      share|improve this question








      edited yesterday









      V2Blast

      25k383155




      25k383155










      asked yesterday









      Ceiling GeckoCeiling Gecko

      283110




      283110






















          3 Answers
          3






          active

          oldest

          votes


















          31












          $begingroup$


          Knock cannot open the portal to a Magnificent Mansion.



          From Magnificent Mansion:




          You conjure an extradimensional dwelling in range that lasts for the duration. You choose where its one entrance is located. The entrance shimmers faintly and is 5 feet wide and 10 feet tall. You and any creature you designate when you cast the spell can enter the extradimensional dwelling as long as the portal remains open. You can open or close the portal if you are within 30 feet of it. While closed, the portal is invisible.




          Let's first assume that you overcome the fact that the Mansion's portal is invisible with a See Invisibility spell (which is reasonable, since Knock and See Invisibility are of the same level).



          Now, let's take a look at Knock:




          Choose an object that you can see within range. The object can be a door, a box, a chest, a set of manacles, a padlock, or another object that contains a mundane or magical means that prevents access.
          A target that is held shut by a mundane lock or that is stuck or barred becomes unlocked, unstuck, or unbarred. If the object has multiple locks, only one of them is unlocked.
          If you choose a target that is held shut with arcane lock, that spell is suppressed for 10 minutes, during which time the target can be opened and shut normally.
          When you cast the spell, a loud knock, audible from as far away as 300 feet, emanates from the target object.




          Emphasis mine. Note that the effect of the Knock spell is not to open a door, but to unlock, unstick, or unbar it, allowing it to be opened normally. If you cast Knock on a locked door, the door unlocks but remains closed. If you cast Knock on a closed, unlocked door, the spell has no effect. In either case, you still need to reach out, turn the knob, and physically open the door.



          The portal to the mansion is not barred, stuck, or locked with a mundane lock. Neither is it locked with an Arcane Lock spell. The Knock spell effects doors that are sealed by these means, and only these means. The portal to the Magnificent Mansion is not locked, barred, stuck, or sealed with an Arcane Lock. It is simply closed. Therefore, Knock will have no effect on it, just as Knock has no effect when cast on a door that is closed but unlocked.






          share|improve this answer









          $endgroup$













          • $begingroup$
            Great answer -- what is the mechanism that keeps creatures that weren't designated at casting time from entering the extradimensional space?
            $endgroup$
            – A C
            18 hours ago










          • $begingroup$
            @AC The mere fact that they were not designated.
            $endgroup$
            – Krzysztof Skibiński
            12 hours ago



















          6












          $begingroup$

          No. I'm basing this on Knock's requirement:




          Choose an object that you can see within range.




          and from Magnificent Mansion:




          While closed, the portal is invisible.




          Since you cannot see the entrance to the dwelling, it is not a valid target for the Knock spell.






          share|improve this answer









          $endgroup$









          • 11




            $begingroup$
            Fully agree - but just for giggles it may be worthwhile to provide an answer assuming someone has See Invisibility running or Truesight.
            $endgroup$
            – NautArch
            yesterday






          • 1




            $begingroup$
            I thought about that. My intuition is that you would then be able to open the portal, but that would do you no good (unless the caster designated you as one of the creatures that can enter the dwelling).
            $endgroup$
            – Raj
            yesterday










          • $begingroup$
            I think you've got good reasoning there and that would be a nice addition to an already clear answer.
            $endgroup$
            – NautArch
            yesterday










          • $begingroup$
            It's questionable whether the portal to the magnificent mansion would even be considered an object
            $endgroup$
            – Ruse
            yesterday



















          -2












          $begingroup$

          Based on the wording of knock:




          Choose an object that you can see within range. The object can be a door, a box, a chest, a set of manacles, a padlock, or another object that contains a mundane or magical means that prevents access.




          you could have Knock reveal the invisible portal to the mansion as that is something which is opened/closed. However,knock lists things which require some sort of key or keyword and as access to the Mansion doesn't I would compare to Magic Circle with how the effect is looking as it were at who is trying to enter and stops them.



          In the case with Magic Circle I would not allow Knock to be used to allow an otherwise blocked creature from entering and similarly I also would not allow Knock to give a creature access to the Mansion.






          share|improve this answer










          New contributor




          Travasty is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
          Check out our Code of Conduct.






          $endgroup$









          • 2




            $begingroup$
            What wording exactly are you basing your first sentence on? That should be the Crux of your argument but just a throwaway line. Quote the relevant part and explain how it proves your point. Answers should not be only about "this is how I would rule" without proper backing and evidence.
            $endgroup$
            – Rubiksmoose
            yesterday










          • $begingroup$
            "Choose an object that you can see within range. The object can be a door, a box, a chest, a set of Manacles, a padlock, or another object that contains a mundane or magical means that prevents access." My phrasing definite should be different for what I am trying to say, with there being a difference between things that require a key to get through and things which have other requirements. You are correct however, my answer is more speculative as I haven't dealt with both of those spells together.
            $endgroup$
            – Travasty
            yesterday










          • $begingroup$
            Ok, edited to better explain.
            $endgroup$
            – Travasty
            yesterday










          • $begingroup$
            How can Knock reveal an invisible portal? Its target requirement is "an object that you can see within range". Are you arguing that a caster with See Invisible or TrueSight active could make it visible to other people? But where in the wording of Knock are you getting the reveal-invisible conclusion?
            $endgroup$
            – Peter Cordes
            12 hours ago











          Your Answer





          StackExchange.ifUsing("editor", function () {
          return StackExchange.using("mathjaxEditing", function () {
          StackExchange.MarkdownEditor.creationCallbacks.add(function (editor, postfix) {
          StackExchange.mathjaxEditing.prepareWmdForMathJax(editor, postfix, [["\$", "\$"]]);
          });
          });
          }, "mathjax-editing");

          StackExchange.ready(function() {
          var channelOptions = {
          tags: "".split(" "),
          id: "122"
          };
          initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

          StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
          // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
          if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
          StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
          createEditor();
          });
          }
          else {
          createEditor();
          }
          });

          function createEditor() {
          StackExchange.prepareEditor({
          heartbeatType: 'answer',
          autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
          convertImagesToLinks: false,
          noModals: true,
          showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
          reputationToPostImages: null,
          bindNavPrevention: true,
          postfix: "",
          imageUploader: {
          brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
          contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
          allowUrls: true
          },
          noCode: true, onDemand: true,
          discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
          ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
          });


          }
          });














          draft saved

          draft discarded


















          StackExchange.ready(
          function () {
          StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2frpg.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f143466%2fcan-a-knock-spell-open-the-door-to-mordenkainens-magnificent-mansion%23new-answer', 'question_page');
          }
          );

          Post as a guest















          Required, but never shown

























          3 Answers
          3






          active

          oldest

          votes








          3 Answers
          3






          active

          oldest

          votes









          active

          oldest

          votes






          active

          oldest

          votes









          31












          $begingroup$


          Knock cannot open the portal to a Magnificent Mansion.



          From Magnificent Mansion:




          You conjure an extradimensional dwelling in range that lasts for the duration. You choose where its one entrance is located. The entrance shimmers faintly and is 5 feet wide and 10 feet tall. You and any creature you designate when you cast the spell can enter the extradimensional dwelling as long as the portal remains open. You can open or close the portal if you are within 30 feet of it. While closed, the portal is invisible.




          Let's first assume that you overcome the fact that the Mansion's portal is invisible with a See Invisibility spell (which is reasonable, since Knock and See Invisibility are of the same level).



          Now, let's take a look at Knock:




          Choose an object that you can see within range. The object can be a door, a box, a chest, a set of manacles, a padlock, or another object that contains a mundane or magical means that prevents access.
          A target that is held shut by a mundane lock or that is stuck or barred becomes unlocked, unstuck, or unbarred. If the object has multiple locks, only one of them is unlocked.
          If you choose a target that is held shut with arcane lock, that spell is suppressed for 10 minutes, during which time the target can be opened and shut normally.
          When you cast the spell, a loud knock, audible from as far away as 300 feet, emanates from the target object.




          Emphasis mine. Note that the effect of the Knock spell is not to open a door, but to unlock, unstick, or unbar it, allowing it to be opened normally. If you cast Knock on a locked door, the door unlocks but remains closed. If you cast Knock on a closed, unlocked door, the spell has no effect. In either case, you still need to reach out, turn the knob, and physically open the door.



          The portal to the mansion is not barred, stuck, or locked with a mundane lock. Neither is it locked with an Arcane Lock spell. The Knock spell effects doors that are sealed by these means, and only these means. The portal to the Magnificent Mansion is not locked, barred, stuck, or sealed with an Arcane Lock. It is simply closed. Therefore, Knock will have no effect on it, just as Knock has no effect when cast on a door that is closed but unlocked.






          share|improve this answer









          $endgroup$













          • $begingroup$
            Great answer -- what is the mechanism that keeps creatures that weren't designated at casting time from entering the extradimensional space?
            $endgroup$
            – A C
            18 hours ago










          • $begingroup$
            @AC The mere fact that they were not designated.
            $endgroup$
            – Krzysztof Skibiński
            12 hours ago
















          31












          $begingroup$


          Knock cannot open the portal to a Magnificent Mansion.



          From Magnificent Mansion:




          You conjure an extradimensional dwelling in range that lasts for the duration. You choose where its one entrance is located. The entrance shimmers faintly and is 5 feet wide and 10 feet tall. You and any creature you designate when you cast the spell can enter the extradimensional dwelling as long as the portal remains open. You can open or close the portal if you are within 30 feet of it. While closed, the portal is invisible.




          Let's first assume that you overcome the fact that the Mansion's portal is invisible with a See Invisibility spell (which is reasonable, since Knock and See Invisibility are of the same level).



          Now, let's take a look at Knock:




          Choose an object that you can see within range. The object can be a door, a box, a chest, a set of manacles, a padlock, or another object that contains a mundane or magical means that prevents access.
          A target that is held shut by a mundane lock or that is stuck or barred becomes unlocked, unstuck, or unbarred. If the object has multiple locks, only one of them is unlocked.
          If you choose a target that is held shut with arcane lock, that spell is suppressed for 10 minutes, during which time the target can be opened and shut normally.
          When you cast the spell, a loud knock, audible from as far away as 300 feet, emanates from the target object.




          Emphasis mine. Note that the effect of the Knock spell is not to open a door, but to unlock, unstick, or unbar it, allowing it to be opened normally. If you cast Knock on a locked door, the door unlocks but remains closed. If you cast Knock on a closed, unlocked door, the spell has no effect. In either case, you still need to reach out, turn the knob, and physically open the door.



          The portal to the mansion is not barred, stuck, or locked with a mundane lock. Neither is it locked with an Arcane Lock spell. The Knock spell effects doors that are sealed by these means, and only these means. The portal to the Magnificent Mansion is not locked, barred, stuck, or sealed with an Arcane Lock. It is simply closed. Therefore, Knock will have no effect on it, just as Knock has no effect when cast on a door that is closed but unlocked.






          share|improve this answer









          $endgroup$













          • $begingroup$
            Great answer -- what is the mechanism that keeps creatures that weren't designated at casting time from entering the extradimensional space?
            $endgroup$
            – A C
            18 hours ago










          • $begingroup$
            @AC The mere fact that they were not designated.
            $endgroup$
            – Krzysztof Skibiński
            12 hours ago














          31












          31








          31





          $begingroup$


          Knock cannot open the portal to a Magnificent Mansion.



          From Magnificent Mansion:




          You conjure an extradimensional dwelling in range that lasts for the duration. You choose where its one entrance is located. The entrance shimmers faintly and is 5 feet wide and 10 feet tall. You and any creature you designate when you cast the spell can enter the extradimensional dwelling as long as the portal remains open. You can open or close the portal if you are within 30 feet of it. While closed, the portal is invisible.




          Let's first assume that you overcome the fact that the Mansion's portal is invisible with a See Invisibility spell (which is reasonable, since Knock and See Invisibility are of the same level).



          Now, let's take a look at Knock:




          Choose an object that you can see within range. The object can be a door, a box, a chest, a set of manacles, a padlock, or another object that contains a mundane or magical means that prevents access.
          A target that is held shut by a mundane lock or that is stuck or barred becomes unlocked, unstuck, or unbarred. If the object has multiple locks, only one of them is unlocked.
          If you choose a target that is held shut with arcane lock, that spell is suppressed for 10 minutes, during which time the target can be opened and shut normally.
          When you cast the spell, a loud knock, audible from as far away as 300 feet, emanates from the target object.




          Emphasis mine. Note that the effect of the Knock spell is not to open a door, but to unlock, unstick, or unbar it, allowing it to be opened normally. If you cast Knock on a locked door, the door unlocks but remains closed. If you cast Knock on a closed, unlocked door, the spell has no effect. In either case, you still need to reach out, turn the knob, and physically open the door.



          The portal to the mansion is not barred, stuck, or locked with a mundane lock. Neither is it locked with an Arcane Lock spell. The Knock spell effects doors that are sealed by these means, and only these means. The portal to the Magnificent Mansion is not locked, barred, stuck, or sealed with an Arcane Lock. It is simply closed. Therefore, Knock will have no effect on it, just as Knock has no effect when cast on a door that is closed but unlocked.






          share|improve this answer









          $endgroup$




          Knock cannot open the portal to a Magnificent Mansion.



          From Magnificent Mansion:




          You conjure an extradimensional dwelling in range that lasts for the duration. You choose where its one entrance is located. The entrance shimmers faintly and is 5 feet wide and 10 feet tall. You and any creature you designate when you cast the spell can enter the extradimensional dwelling as long as the portal remains open. You can open or close the portal if you are within 30 feet of it. While closed, the portal is invisible.




          Let's first assume that you overcome the fact that the Mansion's portal is invisible with a See Invisibility spell (which is reasonable, since Knock and See Invisibility are of the same level).



          Now, let's take a look at Knock:




          Choose an object that you can see within range. The object can be a door, a box, a chest, a set of manacles, a padlock, or another object that contains a mundane or magical means that prevents access.
          A target that is held shut by a mundane lock or that is stuck or barred becomes unlocked, unstuck, or unbarred. If the object has multiple locks, only one of them is unlocked.
          If you choose a target that is held shut with arcane lock, that spell is suppressed for 10 minutes, during which time the target can be opened and shut normally.
          When you cast the spell, a loud knock, audible from as far away as 300 feet, emanates from the target object.




          Emphasis mine. Note that the effect of the Knock spell is not to open a door, but to unlock, unstick, or unbar it, allowing it to be opened normally. If you cast Knock on a locked door, the door unlocks but remains closed. If you cast Knock on a closed, unlocked door, the spell has no effect. In either case, you still need to reach out, turn the knob, and physically open the door.



          The portal to the mansion is not barred, stuck, or locked with a mundane lock. Neither is it locked with an Arcane Lock spell. The Knock spell effects doors that are sealed by these means, and only these means. The portal to the Magnificent Mansion is not locked, barred, stuck, or sealed with an Arcane Lock. It is simply closed. Therefore, Knock will have no effect on it, just as Knock has no effect when cast on a door that is closed but unlocked.







          share|improve this answer












          share|improve this answer



          share|improve this answer










          answered yesterday









          user48255user48255

          4,993929




          4,993929












          • $begingroup$
            Great answer -- what is the mechanism that keeps creatures that weren't designated at casting time from entering the extradimensional space?
            $endgroup$
            – A C
            18 hours ago










          • $begingroup$
            @AC The mere fact that they were not designated.
            $endgroup$
            – Krzysztof Skibiński
            12 hours ago


















          • $begingroup$
            Great answer -- what is the mechanism that keeps creatures that weren't designated at casting time from entering the extradimensional space?
            $endgroup$
            – A C
            18 hours ago










          • $begingroup$
            @AC The mere fact that they were not designated.
            $endgroup$
            – Krzysztof Skibiński
            12 hours ago
















          $begingroup$
          Great answer -- what is the mechanism that keeps creatures that weren't designated at casting time from entering the extradimensional space?
          $endgroup$
          – A C
          18 hours ago




          $begingroup$
          Great answer -- what is the mechanism that keeps creatures that weren't designated at casting time from entering the extradimensional space?
          $endgroup$
          – A C
          18 hours ago












          $begingroup$
          @AC The mere fact that they were not designated.
          $endgroup$
          – Krzysztof Skibiński
          12 hours ago




          $begingroup$
          @AC The mere fact that they were not designated.
          $endgroup$
          – Krzysztof Skibiński
          12 hours ago













          6












          $begingroup$

          No. I'm basing this on Knock's requirement:




          Choose an object that you can see within range.




          and from Magnificent Mansion:




          While closed, the portal is invisible.




          Since you cannot see the entrance to the dwelling, it is not a valid target for the Knock spell.






          share|improve this answer









          $endgroup$









          • 11




            $begingroup$
            Fully agree - but just for giggles it may be worthwhile to provide an answer assuming someone has See Invisibility running or Truesight.
            $endgroup$
            – NautArch
            yesterday






          • 1




            $begingroup$
            I thought about that. My intuition is that you would then be able to open the portal, but that would do you no good (unless the caster designated you as one of the creatures that can enter the dwelling).
            $endgroup$
            – Raj
            yesterday










          • $begingroup$
            I think you've got good reasoning there and that would be a nice addition to an already clear answer.
            $endgroup$
            – NautArch
            yesterday










          • $begingroup$
            It's questionable whether the portal to the magnificent mansion would even be considered an object
            $endgroup$
            – Ruse
            yesterday
















          6












          $begingroup$

          No. I'm basing this on Knock's requirement:




          Choose an object that you can see within range.




          and from Magnificent Mansion:




          While closed, the portal is invisible.




          Since you cannot see the entrance to the dwelling, it is not a valid target for the Knock spell.






          share|improve this answer









          $endgroup$









          • 11




            $begingroup$
            Fully agree - but just for giggles it may be worthwhile to provide an answer assuming someone has See Invisibility running or Truesight.
            $endgroup$
            – NautArch
            yesterday






          • 1




            $begingroup$
            I thought about that. My intuition is that you would then be able to open the portal, but that would do you no good (unless the caster designated you as one of the creatures that can enter the dwelling).
            $endgroup$
            – Raj
            yesterday










          • $begingroup$
            I think you've got good reasoning there and that would be a nice addition to an already clear answer.
            $endgroup$
            – NautArch
            yesterday










          • $begingroup$
            It's questionable whether the portal to the magnificent mansion would even be considered an object
            $endgroup$
            – Ruse
            yesterday














          6












          6








          6





          $begingroup$

          No. I'm basing this on Knock's requirement:




          Choose an object that you can see within range.




          and from Magnificent Mansion:




          While closed, the portal is invisible.




          Since you cannot see the entrance to the dwelling, it is not a valid target for the Knock spell.






          share|improve this answer









          $endgroup$



          No. I'm basing this on Knock's requirement:




          Choose an object that you can see within range.




          and from Magnificent Mansion:




          While closed, the portal is invisible.




          Since you cannot see the entrance to the dwelling, it is not a valid target for the Knock spell.







          share|improve this answer












          share|improve this answer



          share|improve this answer










          answered yesterday









          RajRaj

          385212




          385212








          • 11




            $begingroup$
            Fully agree - but just for giggles it may be worthwhile to provide an answer assuming someone has See Invisibility running or Truesight.
            $endgroup$
            – NautArch
            yesterday






          • 1




            $begingroup$
            I thought about that. My intuition is that you would then be able to open the portal, but that would do you no good (unless the caster designated you as one of the creatures that can enter the dwelling).
            $endgroup$
            – Raj
            yesterday










          • $begingroup$
            I think you've got good reasoning there and that would be a nice addition to an already clear answer.
            $endgroup$
            – NautArch
            yesterday










          • $begingroup$
            It's questionable whether the portal to the magnificent mansion would even be considered an object
            $endgroup$
            – Ruse
            yesterday














          • 11




            $begingroup$
            Fully agree - but just for giggles it may be worthwhile to provide an answer assuming someone has See Invisibility running or Truesight.
            $endgroup$
            – NautArch
            yesterday






          • 1




            $begingroup$
            I thought about that. My intuition is that you would then be able to open the portal, but that would do you no good (unless the caster designated you as one of the creatures that can enter the dwelling).
            $endgroup$
            – Raj
            yesterday










          • $begingroup$
            I think you've got good reasoning there and that would be a nice addition to an already clear answer.
            $endgroup$
            – NautArch
            yesterday










          • $begingroup$
            It's questionable whether the portal to the magnificent mansion would even be considered an object
            $endgroup$
            – Ruse
            yesterday








          11




          11




          $begingroup$
          Fully agree - but just for giggles it may be worthwhile to provide an answer assuming someone has See Invisibility running or Truesight.
          $endgroup$
          – NautArch
          yesterday




          $begingroup$
          Fully agree - but just for giggles it may be worthwhile to provide an answer assuming someone has See Invisibility running or Truesight.
          $endgroup$
          – NautArch
          yesterday




          1




          1




          $begingroup$
          I thought about that. My intuition is that you would then be able to open the portal, but that would do you no good (unless the caster designated you as one of the creatures that can enter the dwelling).
          $endgroup$
          – Raj
          yesterday




          $begingroup$
          I thought about that. My intuition is that you would then be able to open the portal, but that would do you no good (unless the caster designated you as one of the creatures that can enter the dwelling).
          $endgroup$
          – Raj
          yesterday












          $begingroup$
          I think you've got good reasoning there and that would be a nice addition to an already clear answer.
          $endgroup$
          – NautArch
          yesterday




          $begingroup$
          I think you've got good reasoning there and that would be a nice addition to an already clear answer.
          $endgroup$
          – NautArch
          yesterday












          $begingroup$
          It's questionable whether the portal to the magnificent mansion would even be considered an object
          $endgroup$
          – Ruse
          yesterday




          $begingroup$
          It's questionable whether the portal to the magnificent mansion would even be considered an object
          $endgroup$
          – Ruse
          yesterday











          -2












          $begingroup$

          Based on the wording of knock:




          Choose an object that you can see within range. The object can be a door, a box, a chest, a set of manacles, a padlock, or another object that contains a mundane or magical means that prevents access.




          you could have Knock reveal the invisible portal to the mansion as that is something which is opened/closed. However,knock lists things which require some sort of key or keyword and as access to the Mansion doesn't I would compare to Magic Circle with how the effect is looking as it were at who is trying to enter and stops them.



          In the case with Magic Circle I would not allow Knock to be used to allow an otherwise blocked creature from entering and similarly I also would not allow Knock to give a creature access to the Mansion.






          share|improve this answer










          New contributor




          Travasty is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
          Check out our Code of Conduct.






          $endgroup$









          • 2




            $begingroup$
            What wording exactly are you basing your first sentence on? That should be the Crux of your argument but just a throwaway line. Quote the relevant part and explain how it proves your point. Answers should not be only about "this is how I would rule" without proper backing and evidence.
            $endgroup$
            – Rubiksmoose
            yesterday










          • $begingroup$
            "Choose an object that you can see within range. The object can be a door, a box, a chest, a set of Manacles, a padlock, or another object that contains a mundane or magical means that prevents access." My phrasing definite should be different for what I am trying to say, with there being a difference between things that require a key to get through and things which have other requirements. You are correct however, my answer is more speculative as I haven't dealt with both of those spells together.
            $endgroup$
            – Travasty
            yesterday










          • $begingroup$
            Ok, edited to better explain.
            $endgroup$
            – Travasty
            yesterday










          • $begingroup$
            How can Knock reveal an invisible portal? Its target requirement is "an object that you can see within range". Are you arguing that a caster with See Invisible or TrueSight active could make it visible to other people? But where in the wording of Knock are you getting the reveal-invisible conclusion?
            $endgroup$
            – Peter Cordes
            12 hours ago
















          -2












          $begingroup$

          Based on the wording of knock:




          Choose an object that you can see within range. The object can be a door, a box, a chest, a set of manacles, a padlock, or another object that contains a mundane or magical means that prevents access.




          you could have Knock reveal the invisible portal to the mansion as that is something which is opened/closed. However,knock lists things which require some sort of key or keyword and as access to the Mansion doesn't I would compare to Magic Circle with how the effect is looking as it were at who is trying to enter and stops them.



          In the case with Magic Circle I would not allow Knock to be used to allow an otherwise blocked creature from entering and similarly I also would not allow Knock to give a creature access to the Mansion.






          share|improve this answer










          New contributor




          Travasty is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
          Check out our Code of Conduct.






          $endgroup$









          • 2




            $begingroup$
            What wording exactly are you basing your first sentence on? That should be the Crux of your argument but just a throwaway line. Quote the relevant part and explain how it proves your point. Answers should not be only about "this is how I would rule" without proper backing and evidence.
            $endgroup$
            – Rubiksmoose
            yesterday










          • $begingroup$
            "Choose an object that you can see within range. The object can be a door, a box, a chest, a set of Manacles, a padlock, or another object that contains a mundane or magical means that prevents access." My phrasing definite should be different for what I am trying to say, with there being a difference between things that require a key to get through and things which have other requirements. You are correct however, my answer is more speculative as I haven't dealt with both of those spells together.
            $endgroup$
            – Travasty
            yesterday










          • $begingroup$
            Ok, edited to better explain.
            $endgroup$
            – Travasty
            yesterday










          • $begingroup$
            How can Knock reveal an invisible portal? Its target requirement is "an object that you can see within range". Are you arguing that a caster with See Invisible or TrueSight active could make it visible to other people? But where in the wording of Knock are you getting the reveal-invisible conclusion?
            $endgroup$
            – Peter Cordes
            12 hours ago














          -2












          -2








          -2





          $begingroup$

          Based on the wording of knock:




          Choose an object that you can see within range. The object can be a door, a box, a chest, a set of manacles, a padlock, or another object that contains a mundane or magical means that prevents access.




          you could have Knock reveal the invisible portal to the mansion as that is something which is opened/closed. However,knock lists things which require some sort of key or keyword and as access to the Mansion doesn't I would compare to Magic Circle with how the effect is looking as it were at who is trying to enter and stops them.



          In the case with Magic Circle I would not allow Knock to be used to allow an otherwise blocked creature from entering and similarly I also would not allow Knock to give a creature access to the Mansion.






          share|improve this answer










          New contributor




          Travasty is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
          Check out our Code of Conduct.






          $endgroup$



          Based on the wording of knock:




          Choose an object that you can see within range. The object can be a door, a box, a chest, a set of manacles, a padlock, or another object that contains a mundane or magical means that prevents access.




          you could have Knock reveal the invisible portal to the mansion as that is something which is opened/closed. However,knock lists things which require some sort of key or keyword and as access to the Mansion doesn't I would compare to Magic Circle with how the effect is looking as it were at who is trying to enter and stops them.



          In the case with Magic Circle I would not allow Knock to be used to allow an otherwise blocked creature from entering and similarly I also would not allow Knock to give a creature access to the Mansion.







          share|improve this answer










          New contributor




          Travasty is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
          Check out our Code of Conduct.









          share|improve this answer



          share|improve this answer








          edited yesterday









          NautArch

          60.4k8217401




          60.4k8217401






          New contributor




          Travasty is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
          Check out our Code of Conduct.









          answered yesterday









          TravastyTravasty

          192




          192




          New contributor




          Travasty is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
          Check out our Code of Conduct.





          New contributor





          Travasty is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
          Check out our Code of Conduct.






          Travasty is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
          Check out our Code of Conduct.








          • 2




            $begingroup$
            What wording exactly are you basing your first sentence on? That should be the Crux of your argument but just a throwaway line. Quote the relevant part and explain how it proves your point. Answers should not be only about "this is how I would rule" without proper backing and evidence.
            $endgroup$
            – Rubiksmoose
            yesterday










          • $begingroup$
            "Choose an object that you can see within range. The object can be a door, a box, a chest, a set of Manacles, a padlock, or another object that contains a mundane or magical means that prevents access." My phrasing definite should be different for what I am trying to say, with there being a difference between things that require a key to get through and things which have other requirements. You are correct however, my answer is more speculative as I haven't dealt with both of those spells together.
            $endgroup$
            – Travasty
            yesterday










          • $begingroup$
            Ok, edited to better explain.
            $endgroup$
            – Travasty
            yesterday










          • $begingroup$
            How can Knock reveal an invisible portal? Its target requirement is "an object that you can see within range". Are you arguing that a caster with See Invisible or TrueSight active could make it visible to other people? But where in the wording of Knock are you getting the reveal-invisible conclusion?
            $endgroup$
            – Peter Cordes
            12 hours ago














          • 2




            $begingroup$
            What wording exactly are you basing your first sentence on? That should be the Crux of your argument but just a throwaway line. Quote the relevant part and explain how it proves your point. Answers should not be only about "this is how I would rule" without proper backing and evidence.
            $endgroup$
            – Rubiksmoose
            yesterday










          • $begingroup$
            "Choose an object that you can see within range. The object can be a door, a box, a chest, a set of Manacles, a padlock, or another object that contains a mundane or magical means that prevents access." My phrasing definite should be different for what I am trying to say, with there being a difference between things that require a key to get through and things which have other requirements. You are correct however, my answer is more speculative as I haven't dealt with both of those spells together.
            $endgroup$
            – Travasty
            yesterday










          • $begingroup$
            Ok, edited to better explain.
            $endgroup$
            – Travasty
            yesterday










          • $begingroup$
            How can Knock reveal an invisible portal? Its target requirement is "an object that you can see within range". Are you arguing that a caster with See Invisible or TrueSight active could make it visible to other people? But where in the wording of Knock are you getting the reveal-invisible conclusion?
            $endgroup$
            – Peter Cordes
            12 hours ago








          2




          2




          $begingroup$
          What wording exactly are you basing your first sentence on? That should be the Crux of your argument but just a throwaway line. Quote the relevant part and explain how it proves your point. Answers should not be only about "this is how I would rule" without proper backing and evidence.
          $endgroup$
          – Rubiksmoose
          yesterday




          $begingroup$
          What wording exactly are you basing your first sentence on? That should be the Crux of your argument but just a throwaway line. Quote the relevant part and explain how it proves your point. Answers should not be only about "this is how I would rule" without proper backing and evidence.
          $endgroup$
          – Rubiksmoose
          yesterday












          $begingroup$
          "Choose an object that you can see within range. The object can be a door, a box, a chest, a set of Manacles, a padlock, or another object that contains a mundane or magical means that prevents access." My phrasing definite should be different for what I am trying to say, with there being a difference between things that require a key to get through and things which have other requirements. You are correct however, my answer is more speculative as I haven't dealt with both of those spells together.
          $endgroup$
          – Travasty
          yesterday




          $begingroup$
          "Choose an object that you can see within range. The object can be a door, a box, a chest, a set of Manacles, a padlock, or another object that contains a mundane or magical means that prevents access." My phrasing definite should be different for what I am trying to say, with there being a difference between things that require a key to get through and things which have other requirements. You are correct however, my answer is more speculative as I haven't dealt with both of those spells together.
          $endgroup$
          – Travasty
          yesterday












          $begingroup$
          Ok, edited to better explain.
          $endgroup$
          – Travasty
          yesterday




          $begingroup$
          Ok, edited to better explain.
          $endgroup$
          – Travasty
          yesterday












          $begingroup$
          How can Knock reveal an invisible portal? Its target requirement is "an object that you can see within range". Are you arguing that a caster with See Invisible or TrueSight active could make it visible to other people? But where in the wording of Knock are you getting the reveal-invisible conclusion?
          $endgroup$
          – Peter Cordes
          12 hours ago




          $begingroup$
          How can Knock reveal an invisible portal? Its target requirement is "an object that you can see within range". Are you arguing that a caster with See Invisible or TrueSight active could make it visible to other people? But where in the wording of Knock are you getting the reveal-invisible conclusion?
          $endgroup$
          – Peter Cordes
          12 hours ago


















          draft saved

          draft discarded




















































          Thanks for contributing an answer to Role-playing Games Stack Exchange!


          • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

          But avoid



          • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

          • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


          Use MathJax to format equations. MathJax reference.


          To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




          draft saved


          draft discarded














          StackExchange.ready(
          function () {
          StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2frpg.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f143466%2fcan-a-knock-spell-open-the-door-to-mordenkainens-magnificent-mansion%23new-answer', 'question_page');
          }
          );

          Post as a guest















          Required, but never shown





















































          Required, but never shown














          Required, but never shown












          Required, but never shown







          Required, but never shown

































          Required, but never shown














          Required, but never shown












          Required, but never shown







          Required, but never shown







          Popular posts from this blog

          How did Captain America manage to do this?

          迪纳利

          南乌拉尔铁路局