Is preaching recommended or mandatory to a temple priest?












2















Every temple in India has at least one priest. The act of preaching scriptures a recommended act or mandatory act for him?










share|improve this question

























  • Preaching where? in temples?

    – Akshay S
    yesterday











  • Yeah........ @AkshayS

    – hanugm
    yesterday








  • 2





    temples are not for that purpose....nor temples are for prayers.!!!

    – Akshay S
    yesterday











  • @AkshayS i understand its not the exclusive place of prayers as are church or mosque etc.Do you mean it in that sense?

    – Pratimaputra
    yesterday






  • 1





    @AkshayS thats really great.

    – Pratimaputra
    yesterday
















2















Every temple in India has at least one priest. The act of preaching scriptures a recommended act or mandatory act for him?










share|improve this question

























  • Preaching where? in temples?

    – Akshay S
    yesterday











  • Yeah........ @AkshayS

    – hanugm
    yesterday








  • 2





    temples are not for that purpose....nor temples are for prayers.!!!

    – Akshay S
    yesterday











  • @AkshayS i understand its not the exclusive place of prayers as are church or mosque etc.Do you mean it in that sense?

    – Pratimaputra
    yesterday






  • 1





    @AkshayS thats really great.

    – Pratimaputra
    yesterday














2












2








2








Every temple in India has at least one priest. The act of preaching scriptures a recommended act or mandatory act for him?










share|improve this question
















Every temple in India has at least one priest. The act of preaching scriptures a recommended act or mandatory act for him?







scripture temple priests






share|improve this question















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited yesterday







hanugm

















asked yesterday









hanugmhanugm

4,33421345




4,33421345













  • Preaching where? in temples?

    – Akshay S
    yesterday











  • Yeah........ @AkshayS

    – hanugm
    yesterday








  • 2





    temples are not for that purpose....nor temples are for prayers.!!!

    – Akshay S
    yesterday











  • @AkshayS i understand its not the exclusive place of prayers as are church or mosque etc.Do you mean it in that sense?

    – Pratimaputra
    yesterday






  • 1





    @AkshayS thats really great.

    – Pratimaputra
    yesterday



















  • Preaching where? in temples?

    – Akshay S
    yesterday











  • Yeah........ @AkshayS

    – hanugm
    yesterday








  • 2





    temples are not for that purpose....nor temples are for prayers.!!!

    – Akshay S
    yesterday











  • @AkshayS i understand its not the exclusive place of prayers as are church or mosque etc.Do you mean it in that sense?

    – Pratimaputra
    yesterday






  • 1





    @AkshayS thats really great.

    – Pratimaputra
    yesterday

















Preaching where? in temples?

– Akshay S
yesterday





Preaching where? in temples?

– Akshay S
yesterday













Yeah........ @AkshayS

– hanugm
yesterday







Yeah........ @AkshayS

– hanugm
yesterday






2




2





temples are not for that purpose....nor temples are for prayers.!!!

– Akshay S
yesterday





temples are not for that purpose....nor temples are for prayers.!!!

– Akshay S
yesterday













@AkshayS i understand its not the exclusive place of prayers as are church or mosque etc.Do you mean it in that sense?

– Pratimaputra
yesterday





@AkshayS i understand its not the exclusive place of prayers as are church or mosque etc.Do you mean it in that sense?

– Pratimaputra
yesterday




1




1





@AkshayS thats really great.

– Pratimaputra
yesterday





@AkshayS thats really great.

– Pratimaputra
yesterday










1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes


















3














In the Smritis, the temple priests are in fact considered fallen/degraded. Probably because they earn through the act of worshipping.




Manu Smriti 3.152. Physicians, temple-priests, sellers of meat, and
those who subsist by shop-keeping must be avoided at sacrifices
offered to the gods and to the manes.



3.180 (Food) given to a seller of Soma becomes ordure, (that given) to a physician pus and blood, but (that presented) to a temple-priest is
lost,
and (that given) to a usurer finds no place (in the world of the
gods).




Alternate translation from Wisdomlib.org:




सोमविक्रयिणे विष्ठा भिषजे पूयशोणितम् ।
नष्टं देवलके
दत्तमप्रतिष्ठं तु वार्धुषौ ॥ १८० ॥



somavikrayiṇe viṣṭhā bhiṣaje pūyaśoṇitam |
naṣṭaṃ devalake
dattamapratiṣṭhaṃ tu vārdhuṣau || 180 ||



What is given to the Soma-seller becomes ordure; to the physician, pus
and blood; that to the temple-attendant becomes lost; and that to the
usurer has no place.—(180)




The link also gives a similar verse from Mahabharata which is as follows:




Mahābhārata (13.90, 13, 14).—‘What is given to the Soma-seller and to
the physician becomes pus and blood; what is given to the
temple-servant perishes; it is neither here nor there.’




So, it is certainly not their responsibility to teach scriptures.






share|improve this answer


























  • For 3.180 you can read the Sanskrit verse from here: wisdomlib.org/hinduism/book/… @Pratimaputra the word used is Devala

    – Rickross
    yesterday













  • @Pratimaputra Actually the translation I have used has food in it .. this wisdomlib translation has what is ..

    – Rickross
    yesterday











  • Yes that's why they have added it in brackets .. if I now change it to what is .. then it will be a mixture of two translations .. @Pratimaputra

    – Rickross
    yesterday











  • I have now added both the translations .. @Pratimaputra

    – Rickross
    yesterday



















1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes








1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes









active

oldest

votes






active

oldest

votes









3














In the Smritis, the temple priests are in fact considered fallen/degraded. Probably because they earn through the act of worshipping.




Manu Smriti 3.152. Physicians, temple-priests, sellers of meat, and
those who subsist by shop-keeping must be avoided at sacrifices
offered to the gods and to the manes.



3.180 (Food) given to a seller of Soma becomes ordure, (that given) to a physician pus and blood, but (that presented) to a temple-priest is
lost,
and (that given) to a usurer finds no place (in the world of the
gods).




Alternate translation from Wisdomlib.org:




सोमविक्रयिणे विष्ठा भिषजे पूयशोणितम् ।
नष्टं देवलके
दत्तमप्रतिष्ठं तु वार्धुषौ ॥ १८० ॥



somavikrayiṇe viṣṭhā bhiṣaje pūyaśoṇitam |
naṣṭaṃ devalake
dattamapratiṣṭhaṃ tu vārdhuṣau || 180 ||



What is given to the Soma-seller becomes ordure; to the physician, pus
and blood; that to the temple-attendant becomes lost; and that to the
usurer has no place.—(180)




The link also gives a similar verse from Mahabharata which is as follows:




Mahābhārata (13.90, 13, 14).—‘What is given to the Soma-seller and to
the physician becomes pus and blood; what is given to the
temple-servant perishes; it is neither here nor there.’




So, it is certainly not their responsibility to teach scriptures.






share|improve this answer


























  • For 3.180 you can read the Sanskrit verse from here: wisdomlib.org/hinduism/book/… @Pratimaputra the word used is Devala

    – Rickross
    yesterday













  • @Pratimaputra Actually the translation I have used has food in it .. this wisdomlib translation has what is ..

    – Rickross
    yesterday











  • Yes that's why they have added it in brackets .. if I now change it to what is .. then it will be a mixture of two translations .. @Pratimaputra

    – Rickross
    yesterday











  • I have now added both the translations .. @Pratimaputra

    – Rickross
    yesterday
















3














In the Smritis, the temple priests are in fact considered fallen/degraded. Probably because they earn through the act of worshipping.




Manu Smriti 3.152. Physicians, temple-priests, sellers of meat, and
those who subsist by shop-keeping must be avoided at sacrifices
offered to the gods and to the manes.



3.180 (Food) given to a seller of Soma becomes ordure, (that given) to a physician pus and blood, but (that presented) to a temple-priest is
lost,
and (that given) to a usurer finds no place (in the world of the
gods).




Alternate translation from Wisdomlib.org:




सोमविक्रयिणे विष्ठा भिषजे पूयशोणितम् ।
नष्टं देवलके
दत्तमप्रतिष्ठं तु वार्धुषौ ॥ १८० ॥



somavikrayiṇe viṣṭhā bhiṣaje pūyaśoṇitam |
naṣṭaṃ devalake
dattamapratiṣṭhaṃ tu vārdhuṣau || 180 ||



What is given to the Soma-seller becomes ordure; to the physician, pus
and blood; that to the temple-attendant becomes lost; and that to the
usurer has no place.—(180)




The link also gives a similar verse from Mahabharata which is as follows:




Mahābhārata (13.90, 13, 14).—‘What is given to the Soma-seller and to
the physician becomes pus and blood; what is given to the
temple-servant perishes; it is neither here nor there.’




So, it is certainly not their responsibility to teach scriptures.






share|improve this answer


























  • For 3.180 you can read the Sanskrit verse from here: wisdomlib.org/hinduism/book/… @Pratimaputra the word used is Devala

    – Rickross
    yesterday













  • @Pratimaputra Actually the translation I have used has food in it .. this wisdomlib translation has what is ..

    – Rickross
    yesterday











  • Yes that's why they have added it in brackets .. if I now change it to what is .. then it will be a mixture of two translations .. @Pratimaputra

    – Rickross
    yesterday











  • I have now added both the translations .. @Pratimaputra

    – Rickross
    yesterday














3












3








3







In the Smritis, the temple priests are in fact considered fallen/degraded. Probably because they earn through the act of worshipping.




Manu Smriti 3.152. Physicians, temple-priests, sellers of meat, and
those who subsist by shop-keeping must be avoided at sacrifices
offered to the gods and to the manes.



3.180 (Food) given to a seller of Soma becomes ordure, (that given) to a physician pus and blood, but (that presented) to a temple-priest is
lost,
and (that given) to a usurer finds no place (in the world of the
gods).




Alternate translation from Wisdomlib.org:




सोमविक्रयिणे विष्ठा भिषजे पूयशोणितम् ।
नष्टं देवलके
दत्तमप्रतिष्ठं तु वार्धुषौ ॥ १८० ॥



somavikrayiṇe viṣṭhā bhiṣaje pūyaśoṇitam |
naṣṭaṃ devalake
dattamapratiṣṭhaṃ tu vārdhuṣau || 180 ||



What is given to the Soma-seller becomes ordure; to the physician, pus
and blood; that to the temple-attendant becomes lost; and that to the
usurer has no place.—(180)




The link also gives a similar verse from Mahabharata which is as follows:




Mahābhārata (13.90, 13, 14).—‘What is given to the Soma-seller and to
the physician becomes pus and blood; what is given to the
temple-servant perishes; it is neither here nor there.’




So, it is certainly not their responsibility to teach scriptures.






share|improve this answer















In the Smritis, the temple priests are in fact considered fallen/degraded. Probably because they earn through the act of worshipping.




Manu Smriti 3.152. Physicians, temple-priests, sellers of meat, and
those who subsist by shop-keeping must be avoided at sacrifices
offered to the gods and to the manes.



3.180 (Food) given to a seller of Soma becomes ordure, (that given) to a physician pus and blood, but (that presented) to a temple-priest is
lost,
and (that given) to a usurer finds no place (in the world of the
gods).




Alternate translation from Wisdomlib.org:




सोमविक्रयिणे विष्ठा भिषजे पूयशोणितम् ।
नष्टं देवलके
दत्तमप्रतिष्ठं तु वार्धुषौ ॥ १८० ॥



somavikrayiṇe viṣṭhā bhiṣaje pūyaśoṇitam |
naṣṭaṃ devalake
dattamapratiṣṭhaṃ tu vārdhuṣau || 180 ||



What is given to the Soma-seller becomes ordure; to the physician, pus
and blood; that to the temple-attendant becomes lost; and that to the
usurer has no place.—(180)




The link also gives a similar verse from Mahabharata which is as follows:




Mahābhārata (13.90, 13, 14).—‘What is given to the Soma-seller and to
the physician becomes pus and blood; what is given to the
temple-servant perishes; it is neither here nor there.’




So, it is certainly not their responsibility to teach scriptures.







share|improve this answer














share|improve this answer



share|improve this answer








edited yesterday

























answered yesterday









RickrossRickross

54k378191




54k378191













  • For 3.180 you can read the Sanskrit verse from here: wisdomlib.org/hinduism/book/… @Pratimaputra the word used is Devala

    – Rickross
    yesterday













  • @Pratimaputra Actually the translation I have used has food in it .. this wisdomlib translation has what is ..

    – Rickross
    yesterday











  • Yes that's why they have added it in brackets .. if I now change it to what is .. then it will be a mixture of two translations .. @Pratimaputra

    – Rickross
    yesterday











  • I have now added both the translations .. @Pratimaputra

    – Rickross
    yesterday



















  • For 3.180 you can read the Sanskrit verse from here: wisdomlib.org/hinduism/book/… @Pratimaputra the word used is Devala

    – Rickross
    yesterday













  • @Pratimaputra Actually the translation I have used has food in it .. this wisdomlib translation has what is ..

    – Rickross
    yesterday











  • Yes that's why they have added it in brackets .. if I now change it to what is .. then it will be a mixture of two translations .. @Pratimaputra

    – Rickross
    yesterday











  • I have now added both the translations .. @Pratimaputra

    – Rickross
    yesterday

















For 3.180 you can read the Sanskrit verse from here: wisdomlib.org/hinduism/book/… @Pratimaputra the word used is Devala

– Rickross
yesterday







For 3.180 you can read the Sanskrit verse from here: wisdomlib.org/hinduism/book/… @Pratimaputra the word used is Devala

– Rickross
yesterday















@Pratimaputra Actually the translation I have used has food in it .. this wisdomlib translation has what is ..

– Rickross
yesterday





@Pratimaputra Actually the translation I have used has food in it .. this wisdomlib translation has what is ..

– Rickross
yesterday













Yes that's why they have added it in brackets .. if I now change it to what is .. then it will be a mixture of two translations .. @Pratimaputra

– Rickross
yesterday





Yes that's why they have added it in brackets .. if I now change it to what is .. then it will be a mixture of two translations .. @Pratimaputra

– Rickross
yesterday













I have now added both the translations .. @Pratimaputra

– Rickross
yesterday





I have now added both the translations .. @Pratimaputra

– Rickross
yesterday



Popular posts from this blog

How did Captain America manage to do this?

迪纳利

南乌拉尔铁路局