How was Herodotus able to get accounts of the Battle of Thermopylae?











up vote
4
down vote

favorite












How was Herodotus able to get accounts of the last stand of Thermopylae if the entire rear guard died alongside Leonidas? It is said he recorded the last words of the Spartans "stranger go tell Sparta we lie here obedient to her laws " and the fall of Leonidas and the Homeric battle of both sides to recover his corpse.










share|improve this question
























  • That is not the last words of the Spartans, but the wording of an inscription that Herodotus states was erected above the graves of the Spartans "there in their honour by the Amphictyons".
    – sempaiscuba
    9 hours ago










  • Wikipedia: "Leonidas, aware that his force was being outflanked, dismissed the bulk of the Greek army and remained to guard their retreat with 300 Spartans and 700 Thespians, fighting to the death. Others also reportedly remained, including up to 900 helots and 400 Thebans; these Thebans mostly reportedly surrendered."
    – Spencer
    8 hours ago

















up vote
4
down vote

favorite












How was Herodotus able to get accounts of the last stand of Thermopylae if the entire rear guard died alongside Leonidas? It is said he recorded the last words of the Spartans "stranger go tell Sparta we lie here obedient to her laws " and the fall of Leonidas and the Homeric battle of both sides to recover his corpse.










share|improve this question
























  • That is not the last words of the Spartans, but the wording of an inscription that Herodotus states was erected above the graves of the Spartans "there in their honour by the Amphictyons".
    – sempaiscuba
    9 hours ago










  • Wikipedia: "Leonidas, aware that his force was being outflanked, dismissed the bulk of the Greek army and remained to guard their retreat with 300 Spartans and 700 Thespians, fighting to the death. Others also reportedly remained, including up to 900 helots and 400 Thebans; these Thebans mostly reportedly surrendered."
    – Spencer
    8 hours ago















up vote
4
down vote

favorite









up vote
4
down vote

favorite











How was Herodotus able to get accounts of the last stand of Thermopylae if the entire rear guard died alongside Leonidas? It is said he recorded the last words of the Spartans "stranger go tell Sparta we lie here obedient to her laws " and the fall of Leonidas and the Homeric battle of both sides to recover his corpse.










share|improve this question















How was Herodotus able to get accounts of the last stand of Thermopylae if the entire rear guard died alongside Leonidas? It is said he recorded the last words of the Spartans "stranger go tell Sparta we lie here obedient to her laws " and the fall of Leonidas and the Homeric battle of both sides to recover his corpse.







ancient-greece greece historical-accuracy






share|improve this question















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited 38 mins ago









sempaiscuba

46k5159204




46k5159204










asked 11 hours ago









Hao Sun

31928




31928












  • That is not the last words of the Spartans, but the wording of an inscription that Herodotus states was erected above the graves of the Spartans "there in their honour by the Amphictyons".
    – sempaiscuba
    9 hours ago










  • Wikipedia: "Leonidas, aware that his force was being outflanked, dismissed the bulk of the Greek army and remained to guard their retreat with 300 Spartans and 700 Thespians, fighting to the death. Others also reportedly remained, including up to 900 helots and 400 Thebans; these Thebans mostly reportedly surrendered."
    – Spencer
    8 hours ago




















  • That is not the last words of the Spartans, but the wording of an inscription that Herodotus states was erected above the graves of the Spartans "there in their honour by the Amphictyons".
    – sempaiscuba
    9 hours ago










  • Wikipedia: "Leonidas, aware that his force was being outflanked, dismissed the bulk of the Greek army and remained to guard their retreat with 300 Spartans and 700 Thespians, fighting to the death. Others also reportedly remained, including up to 900 helots and 400 Thebans; these Thebans mostly reportedly surrendered."
    – Spencer
    8 hours ago


















That is not the last words of the Spartans, but the wording of an inscription that Herodotus states was erected above the graves of the Spartans "there in their honour by the Amphictyons".
– sempaiscuba
9 hours ago




That is not the last words of the Spartans, but the wording of an inscription that Herodotus states was erected above the graves of the Spartans "there in their honour by the Amphictyons".
– sempaiscuba
9 hours ago












Wikipedia: "Leonidas, aware that his force was being outflanked, dismissed the bulk of the Greek army and remained to guard their retreat with 300 Spartans and 700 Thespians, fighting to the death. Others also reportedly remained, including up to 900 helots and 400 Thebans; these Thebans mostly reportedly surrendered."
– Spencer
8 hours ago






Wikipedia: "Leonidas, aware that his force was being outflanked, dismissed the bulk of the Greek army and remained to guard their retreat with 300 Spartans and 700 Thespians, fighting to the death. Others also reportedly remained, including up to 900 helots and 400 Thebans; these Thebans mostly reportedly surrendered."
– Spencer
8 hours ago












2 Answers
2






active

oldest

votes

















up vote
7
down vote



accepted










Firstly, your assertion that:



> It is said he recorded the last words of the Spartans "stranger go tell Sparta we lie here obedient to her laws "



is incorrect.



That is actually the wording of an inscription that Herodotus states was erected above the graves of the Spartans. In fact, Herodotus records that three inscriptions were put there (Book VII, 228). The first was dedicated to all those who died on the Greek side:




μυριάσιν ποτὲ τῇδε τριηκοσίας ἐμάχοντο ἐκ Πελοποννάσου χιλίαδες τέτορες.




[translation]




Four thousand warriors, flower of Pelops' land, Did here against three hundred myriads stand.




The second (the one you mentioned) dedicated to the Spartans:




ὦ ξεῖν’, ἀγγέλλειν Λακεδαιμονίοις ὅτι τῇδε κείμεθα τοῖσι κείνων ῥήμασι πειθόμενοι.




[translation]




Go tell the Spartans, thou that passest by, that here obedient to their words we lie.




And finally one dedicated to the seer, Megistias:




μνῆμα τόδε κλεινοῖο Μεγιστία, ὄν ποτε Μῆδοι Σπερχειὸν ποταμὸν κτεῖναν ἀμειψάμενοι, Μάντιος, ὃς τότε κῆρας ἐπερχομένας σάφα εἰδώς οὐκ ἔτλη Σπάρτης ἡγεμόνα προλιπεῖν.




[translation]




Here fought and fell Megistias, hero brave, slain by the Medes, who crossed Spercheius' wave; Well knew the seer his doom, but scorned to fly, And rather chose with Sparta's king to die.




Herodotus states simply that:




ἐπιγράμμασι μέν νυν καὶ στήλῃσι, ἔξω ἢ τὸ τοῦ μάντιος ἐπίγραμμα, Ἀμφικτύονες εἰσὶ σφέας οἱ ἐπικοσμήσαντες· τὸ δὲ τοῦ μάντιος Μεγιστίεω Σιμωνίδης ὁ Λεωπρέπεος ἐστὶ κατὰ ξεινίην ὁ ἐπιγράψας




[translation]




The inscriptions and the pillars were set there in their honour by the Amphictyons, except the epitaph of the diviner Megistias; that inscription was made for him for friendship's sake by Simonides son of Leoprepes.






As to your main question,



> How was Herodotus able to get accounts of the last stand of Thermopylae if the entire rear guard died alongside Leonidas?



The answer is simply that the entire rear-guard did not die.



Many of the Thebans surrendered to the Persians when they got the chance:




As for the Thebans, whose general was Leontiades, they were for a while with the Greeks and constrained by necessity to fight against the king's army; but as soon as they saw the Persians gaining the upper hand, then, when the Greeks with Leonidas were pressing towards the hillock, the Thebans separated from them and drew nigh to the foreigners, holding out their hands and crying that they were the Persians' men and had been among the first to give earth and water to the king.






  • Book VII, 233 (my emphasis)


Herodotus states that they were branded with Xerxes mark, but - although it is not explicitly stated - they presumably survived to tell their version of events:




... most of them were branded by Xerxes' command with the king's marks, from their general Leontiades downwards.




Furthermore, there would have been survivors of the invasion from the Persian side who had been present at Thermopylae .





Remember that Herodotus was born c 484 BCE, and the Battle of Thermopylae was fought in 480 BCE, just a few years later. He would have been able to ask the survivors of the battle directly, or speak to others who had done so when he was too young.



Although Herodotus' account is all that has come down to us, the story would certainly have been a part of the oral tradition of the people of Greece who lived through the Persian invasion. That traditional version would probably have been the version that he recorded in his Histories.






share|improve this answer






























    up vote
    3
    down vote













    According to Herodotus, "Stranger go tell..." is not the last words by a Spartan, but the inscription on the monument which was installed after the battle. (Book VII, 228). It is clear that Herodotus could see this monument.



    Concerning other details, the battle happened during the life time of Herodotus, though he was very young. So he could interview the survivors, or people who knew the survivors, and also people who fought on the Persian side (many of them were Greeks).






    share|improve this answer



















    • 1




      "…if entire rear guard died…" – so, how did Herodotus interview 'survivors'?
      – LangLangC
      8 hours ago






    • 1




      @LangLangC - Well...presumably there were lots of survivors on the Persian side. Also, it wasn't just the famous "300" in the rearguard, and while the force was wiped out, presumably some prisoners were taken too (it would have been a military imperitive to do so just for the intelligence value). Personally I'm skeptical he ever "interviewed" anyone with first-hand knowledge, but it would have been possible.
      – T.E.D.
      8 hours ago








    • 1




      @T.E.D. Sure. But neither is that explicit in the A, quite counter-intuitively in fact. Nor/And then there are likely observers around, contrary to 300 cinematography, and not all Greek-side fighters died (Thespians, Athenians; where was Ephialtes? etc.). The plus-side an this A is the focus on the Monument. The minus is lack of specifics to what is known. "Survivors", when, where, who, under what conditions reported what (even conjecture based on known reports).
      – LangLangC
      7 hours ago











    Your Answer








    StackExchange.ready(function() {
    var channelOptions = {
    tags: "".split(" "),
    id: "324"
    };
    initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

    StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
    // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
    if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
    StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
    createEditor();
    });
    }
    else {
    createEditor();
    }
    });

    function createEditor() {
    StackExchange.prepareEditor({
    heartbeatType: 'answer',
    convertImagesToLinks: false,
    noModals: true,
    showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
    reputationToPostImages: null,
    bindNavPrevention: true,
    postfix: "",
    imageUploader: {
    brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
    contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
    allowUrls: true
    },
    noCode: true, onDemand: true,
    discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
    ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
    });


    }
    });














    draft saved

    draft discarded


















    StackExchange.ready(
    function () {
    StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fhistory.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f49800%2fhow-was-herodotus-able-to-get-accounts-of-the-battle-of-thermopylae%23new-answer', 'question_page');
    }
    );

    Post as a guest















    Required, but never shown

























    2 Answers
    2






    active

    oldest

    votes








    2 Answers
    2






    active

    oldest

    votes









    active

    oldest

    votes






    active

    oldest

    votes








    up vote
    7
    down vote



    accepted










    Firstly, your assertion that:



    > It is said he recorded the last words of the Spartans "stranger go tell Sparta we lie here obedient to her laws "



    is incorrect.



    That is actually the wording of an inscription that Herodotus states was erected above the graves of the Spartans. In fact, Herodotus records that three inscriptions were put there (Book VII, 228). The first was dedicated to all those who died on the Greek side:




    μυριάσιν ποτὲ τῇδε τριηκοσίας ἐμάχοντο ἐκ Πελοποννάσου χιλίαδες τέτορες.




    [translation]




    Four thousand warriors, flower of Pelops' land, Did here against three hundred myriads stand.




    The second (the one you mentioned) dedicated to the Spartans:




    ὦ ξεῖν’, ἀγγέλλειν Λακεδαιμονίοις ὅτι τῇδε κείμεθα τοῖσι κείνων ῥήμασι πειθόμενοι.




    [translation]




    Go tell the Spartans, thou that passest by, that here obedient to their words we lie.




    And finally one dedicated to the seer, Megistias:




    μνῆμα τόδε κλεινοῖο Μεγιστία, ὄν ποτε Μῆδοι Σπερχειὸν ποταμὸν κτεῖναν ἀμειψάμενοι, Μάντιος, ὃς τότε κῆρας ἐπερχομένας σάφα εἰδώς οὐκ ἔτλη Σπάρτης ἡγεμόνα προλιπεῖν.




    [translation]




    Here fought and fell Megistias, hero brave, slain by the Medes, who crossed Spercheius' wave; Well knew the seer his doom, but scorned to fly, And rather chose with Sparta's king to die.




    Herodotus states simply that:




    ἐπιγράμμασι μέν νυν καὶ στήλῃσι, ἔξω ἢ τὸ τοῦ μάντιος ἐπίγραμμα, Ἀμφικτύονες εἰσὶ σφέας οἱ ἐπικοσμήσαντες· τὸ δὲ τοῦ μάντιος Μεγιστίεω Σιμωνίδης ὁ Λεωπρέπεος ἐστὶ κατὰ ξεινίην ὁ ἐπιγράψας




    [translation]




    The inscriptions and the pillars were set there in their honour by the Amphictyons, except the epitaph of the diviner Megistias; that inscription was made for him for friendship's sake by Simonides son of Leoprepes.






    As to your main question,



    > How was Herodotus able to get accounts of the last stand of Thermopylae if the entire rear guard died alongside Leonidas?



    The answer is simply that the entire rear-guard did not die.



    Many of the Thebans surrendered to the Persians when they got the chance:




    As for the Thebans, whose general was Leontiades, they were for a while with the Greeks and constrained by necessity to fight against the king's army; but as soon as they saw the Persians gaining the upper hand, then, when the Greeks with Leonidas were pressing towards the hillock, the Thebans separated from them and drew nigh to the foreigners, holding out their hands and crying that they were the Persians' men and had been among the first to give earth and water to the king.






    • Book VII, 233 (my emphasis)


    Herodotus states that they were branded with Xerxes mark, but - although it is not explicitly stated - they presumably survived to tell their version of events:




    ... most of them were branded by Xerxes' command with the king's marks, from their general Leontiades downwards.




    Furthermore, there would have been survivors of the invasion from the Persian side who had been present at Thermopylae .





    Remember that Herodotus was born c 484 BCE, and the Battle of Thermopylae was fought in 480 BCE, just a few years later. He would have been able to ask the survivors of the battle directly, or speak to others who had done so when he was too young.



    Although Herodotus' account is all that has come down to us, the story would certainly have been a part of the oral tradition of the people of Greece who lived through the Persian invasion. That traditional version would probably have been the version that he recorded in his Histories.






    share|improve this answer



























      up vote
      7
      down vote



      accepted










      Firstly, your assertion that:



      > It is said he recorded the last words of the Spartans "stranger go tell Sparta we lie here obedient to her laws "



      is incorrect.



      That is actually the wording of an inscription that Herodotus states was erected above the graves of the Spartans. In fact, Herodotus records that three inscriptions were put there (Book VII, 228). The first was dedicated to all those who died on the Greek side:




      μυριάσιν ποτὲ τῇδε τριηκοσίας ἐμάχοντο ἐκ Πελοποννάσου χιλίαδες τέτορες.




      [translation]




      Four thousand warriors, flower of Pelops' land, Did here against three hundred myriads stand.




      The second (the one you mentioned) dedicated to the Spartans:




      ὦ ξεῖν’, ἀγγέλλειν Λακεδαιμονίοις ὅτι τῇδε κείμεθα τοῖσι κείνων ῥήμασι πειθόμενοι.




      [translation]




      Go tell the Spartans, thou that passest by, that here obedient to their words we lie.




      And finally one dedicated to the seer, Megistias:




      μνῆμα τόδε κλεινοῖο Μεγιστία, ὄν ποτε Μῆδοι Σπερχειὸν ποταμὸν κτεῖναν ἀμειψάμενοι, Μάντιος, ὃς τότε κῆρας ἐπερχομένας σάφα εἰδώς οὐκ ἔτλη Σπάρτης ἡγεμόνα προλιπεῖν.




      [translation]




      Here fought and fell Megistias, hero brave, slain by the Medes, who crossed Spercheius' wave; Well knew the seer his doom, but scorned to fly, And rather chose with Sparta's king to die.




      Herodotus states simply that:




      ἐπιγράμμασι μέν νυν καὶ στήλῃσι, ἔξω ἢ τὸ τοῦ μάντιος ἐπίγραμμα, Ἀμφικτύονες εἰσὶ σφέας οἱ ἐπικοσμήσαντες· τὸ δὲ τοῦ μάντιος Μεγιστίεω Σιμωνίδης ὁ Λεωπρέπεος ἐστὶ κατὰ ξεινίην ὁ ἐπιγράψας




      [translation]




      The inscriptions and the pillars were set there in their honour by the Amphictyons, except the epitaph of the diviner Megistias; that inscription was made for him for friendship's sake by Simonides son of Leoprepes.






      As to your main question,



      > How was Herodotus able to get accounts of the last stand of Thermopylae if the entire rear guard died alongside Leonidas?



      The answer is simply that the entire rear-guard did not die.



      Many of the Thebans surrendered to the Persians when they got the chance:




      As for the Thebans, whose general was Leontiades, they were for a while with the Greeks and constrained by necessity to fight against the king's army; but as soon as they saw the Persians gaining the upper hand, then, when the Greeks with Leonidas were pressing towards the hillock, the Thebans separated from them and drew nigh to the foreigners, holding out their hands and crying that they were the Persians' men and had been among the first to give earth and water to the king.






      • Book VII, 233 (my emphasis)


      Herodotus states that they were branded with Xerxes mark, but - although it is not explicitly stated - they presumably survived to tell their version of events:




      ... most of them were branded by Xerxes' command with the king's marks, from their general Leontiades downwards.




      Furthermore, there would have been survivors of the invasion from the Persian side who had been present at Thermopylae .





      Remember that Herodotus was born c 484 BCE, and the Battle of Thermopylae was fought in 480 BCE, just a few years later. He would have been able to ask the survivors of the battle directly, or speak to others who had done so when he was too young.



      Although Herodotus' account is all that has come down to us, the story would certainly have been a part of the oral tradition of the people of Greece who lived through the Persian invasion. That traditional version would probably have been the version that he recorded in his Histories.






      share|improve this answer

























        up vote
        7
        down vote



        accepted







        up vote
        7
        down vote



        accepted






        Firstly, your assertion that:



        > It is said he recorded the last words of the Spartans "stranger go tell Sparta we lie here obedient to her laws "



        is incorrect.



        That is actually the wording of an inscription that Herodotus states was erected above the graves of the Spartans. In fact, Herodotus records that three inscriptions were put there (Book VII, 228). The first was dedicated to all those who died on the Greek side:




        μυριάσιν ποτὲ τῇδε τριηκοσίας ἐμάχοντο ἐκ Πελοποννάσου χιλίαδες τέτορες.




        [translation]




        Four thousand warriors, flower of Pelops' land, Did here against three hundred myriads stand.




        The second (the one you mentioned) dedicated to the Spartans:




        ὦ ξεῖν’, ἀγγέλλειν Λακεδαιμονίοις ὅτι τῇδε κείμεθα τοῖσι κείνων ῥήμασι πειθόμενοι.




        [translation]




        Go tell the Spartans, thou that passest by, that here obedient to their words we lie.




        And finally one dedicated to the seer, Megistias:




        μνῆμα τόδε κλεινοῖο Μεγιστία, ὄν ποτε Μῆδοι Σπερχειὸν ποταμὸν κτεῖναν ἀμειψάμενοι, Μάντιος, ὃς τότε κῆρας ἐπερχομένας σάφα εἰδώς οὐκ ἔτλη Σπάρτης ἡγεμόνα προλιπεῖν.




        [translation]




        Here fought and fell Megistias, hero brave, slain by the Medes, who crossed Spercheius' wave; Well knew the seer his doom, but scorned to fly, And rather chose with Sparta's king to die.




        Herodotus states simply that:




        ἐπιγράμμασι μέν νυν καὶ στήλῃσι, ἔξω ἢ τὸ τοῦ μάντιος ἐπίγραμμα, Ἀμφικτύονες εἰσὶ σφέας οἱ ἐπικοσμήσαντες· τὸ δὲ τοῦ μάντιος Μεγιστίεω Σιμωνίδης ὁ Λεωπρέπεος ἐστὶ κατὰ ξεινίην ὁ ἐπιγράψας




        [translation]




        The inscriptions and the pillars were set there in their honour by the Amphictyons, except the epitaph of the diviner Megistias; that inscription was made for him for friendship's sake by Simonides son of Leoprepes.






        As to your main question,



        > How was Herodotus able to get accounts of the last stand of Thermopylae if the entire rear guard died alongside Leonidas?



        The answer is simply that the entire rear-guard did not die.



        Many of the Thebans surrendered to the Persians when they got the chance:




        As for the Thebans, whose general was Leontiades, they were for a while with the Greeks and constrained by necessity to fight against the king's army; but as soon as they saw the Persians gaining the upper hand, then, when the Greeks with Leonidas were pressing towards the hillock, the Thebans separated from them and drew nigh to the foreigners, holding out their hands and crying that they were the Persians' men and had been among the first to give earth and water to the king.






        • Book VII, 233 (my emphasis)


        Herodotus states that they were branded with Xerxes mark, but - although it is not explicitly stated - they presumably survived to tell their version of events:




        ... most of them were branded by Xerxes' command with the king's marks, from their general Leontiades downwards.




        Furthermore, there would have been survivors of the invasion from the Persian side who had been present at Thermopylae .





        Remember that Herodotus was born c 484 BCE, and the Battle of Thermopylae was fought in 480 BCE, just a few years later. He would have been able to ask the survivors of the battle directly, or speak to others who had done so when he was too young.



        Although Herodotus' account is all that has come down to us, the story would certainly have been a part of the oral tradition of the people of Greece who lived through the Persian invasion. That traditional version would probably have been the version that he recorded in his Histories.






        share|improve this answer














        Firstly, your assertion that:



        > It is said he recorded the last words of the Spartans "stranger go tell Sparta we lie here obedient to her laws "



        is incorrect.



        That is actually the wording of an inscription that Herodotus states was erected above the graves of the Spartans. In fact, Herodotus records that three inscriptions were put there (Book VII, 228). The first was dedicated to all those who died on the Greek side:




        μυριάσιν ποτὲ τῇδε τριηκοσίας ἐμάχοντο ἐκ Πελοποννάσου χιλίαδες τέτορες.




        [translation]




        Four thousand warriors, flower of Pelops' land, Did here against three hundred myriads stand.




        The second (the one you mentioned) dedicated to the Spartans:




        ὦ ξεῖν’, ἀγγέλλειν Λακεδαιμονίοις ὅτι τῇδε κείμεθα τοῖσι κείνων ῥήμασι πειθόμενοι.




        [translation]




        Go tell the Spartans, thou that passest by, that here obedient to their words we lie.




        And finally one dedicated to the seer, Megistias:




        μνῆμα τόδε κλεινοῖο Μεγιστία, ὄν ποτε Μῆδοι Σπερχειὸν ποταμὸν κτεῖναν ἀμειψάμενοι, Μάντιος, ὃς τότε κῆρας ἐπερχομένας σάφα εἰδώς οὐκ ἔτλη Σπάρτης ἡγεμόνα προλιπεῖν.




        [translation]




        Here fought and fell Megistias, hero brave, slain by the Medes, who crossed Spercheius' wave; Well knew the seer his doom, but scorned to fly, And rather chose with Sparta's king to die.




        Herodotus states simply that:




        ἐπιγράμμασι μέν νυν καὶ στήλῃσι, ἔξω ἢ τὸ τοῦ μάντιος ἐπίγραμμα, Ἀμφικτύονες εἰσὶ σφέας οἱ ἐπικοσμήσαντες· τὸ δὲ τοῦ μάντιος Μεγιστίεω Σιμωνίδης ὁ Λεωπρέπεος ἐστὶ κατὰ ξεινίην ὁ ἐπιγράψας




        [translation]




        The inscriptions and the pillars were set there in their honour by the Amphictyons, except the epitaph of the diviner Megistias; that inscription was made for him for friendship's sake by Simonides son of Leoprepes.






        As to your main question,



        > How was Herodotus able to get accounts of the last stand of Thermopylae if the entire rear guard died alongside Leonidas?



        The answer is simply that the entire rear-guard did not die.



        Many of the Thebans surrendered to the Persians when they got the chance:




        As for the Thebans, whose general was Leontiades, they were for a while with the Greeks and constrained by necessity to fight against the king's army; but as soon as they saw the Persians gaining the upper hand, then, when the Greeks with Leonidas were pressing towards the hillock, the Thebans separated from them and drew nigh to the foreigners, holding out their hands and crying that they were the Persians' men and had been among the first to give earth and water to the king.






        • Book VII, 233 (my emphasis)


        Herodotus states that they were branded with Xerxes mark, but - although it is not explicitly stated - they presumably survived to tell their version of events:




        ... most of them were branded by Xerxes' command with the king's marks, from their general Leontiades downwards.




        Furthermore, there would have been survivors of the invasion from the Persian side who had been present at Thermopylae .





        Remember that Herodotus was born c 484 BCE, and the Battle of Thermopylae was fought in 480 BCE, just a few years later. He would have been able to ask the survivors of the battle directly, or speak to others who had done so when he was too young.



        Although Herodotus' account is all that has come down to us, the story would certainly have been a part of the oral tradition of the people of Greece who lived through the Persian invasion. That traditional version would probably have been the version that he recorded in his Histories.







        share|improve this answer














        share|improve this answer



        share|improve this answer








        edited 2 hours ago

























        answered 7 hours ago









        sempaiscuba

        46k5159204




        46k5159204






















            up vote
            3
            down vote













            According to Herodotus, "Stranger go tell..." is not the last words by a Spartan, but the inscription on the monument which was installed after the battle. (Book VII, 228). It is clear that Herodotus could see this monument.



            Concerning other details, the battle happened during the life time of Herodotus, though he was very young. So he could interview the survivors, or people who knew the survivors, and also people who fought on the Persian side (many of them were Greeks).






            share|improve this answer



















            • 1




              "…if entire rear guard died…" – so, how did Herodotus interview 'survivors'?
              – LangLangC
              8 hours ago






            • 1




              @LangLangC - Well...presumably there were lots of survivors on the Persian side. Also, it wasn't just the famous "300" in the rearguard, and while the force was wiped out, presumably some prisoners were taken too (it would have been a military imperitive to do so just for the intelligence value). Personally I'm skeptical he ever "interviewed" anyone with first-hand knowledge, but it would have been possible.
              – T.E.D.
              8 hours ago








            • 1




              @T.E.D. Sure. But neither is that explicit in the A, quite counter-intuitively in fact. Nor/And then there are likely observers around, contrary to 300 cinematography, and not all Greek-side fighters died (Thespians, Athenians; where was Ephialtes? etc.). The plus-side an this A is the focus on the Monument. The minus is lack of specifics to what is known. "Survivors", when, where, who, under what conditions reported what (even conjecture based on known reports).
              – LangLangC
              7 hours ago















            up vote
            3
            down vote













            According to Herodotus, "Stranger go tell..." is not the last words by a Spartan, but the inscription on the monument which was installed after the battle. (Book VII, 228). It is clear that Herodotus could see this monument.



            Concerning other details, the battle happened during the life time of Herodotus, though he was very young. So he could interview the survivors, or people who knew the survivors, and also people who fought on the Persian side (many of them were Greeks).






            share|improve this answer



















            • 1




              "…if entire rear guard died…" – so, how did Herodotus interview 'survivors'?
              – LangLangC
              8 hours ago






            • 1




              @LangLangC - Well...presumably there were lots of survivors on the Persian side. Also, it wasn't just the famous "300" in the rearguard, and while the force was wiped out, presumably some prisoners were taken too (it would have been a military imperitive to do so just for the intelligence value). Personally I'm skeptical he ever "interviewed" anyone with first-hand knowledge, but it would have been possible.
              – T.E.D.
              8 hours ago








            • 1




              @T.E.D. Sure. But neither is that explicit in the A, quite counter-intuitively in fact. Nor/And then there are likely observers around, contrary to 300 cinematography, and not all Greek-side fighters died (Thespians, Athenians; where was Ephialtes? etc.). The plus-side an this A is the focus on the Monument. The minus is lack of specifics to what is known. "Survivors", when, where, who, under what conditions reported what (even conjecture based on known reports).
              – LangLangC
              7 hours ago













            up vote
            3
            down vote










            up vote
            3
            down vote









            According to Herodotus, "Stranger go tell..." is not the last words by a Spartan, but the inscription on the monument which was installed after the battle. (Book VII, 228). It is clear that Herodotus could see this monument.



            Concerning other details, the battle happened during the life time of Herodotus, though he was very young. So he could interview the survivors, or people who knew the survivors, and also people who fought on the Persian side (many of them were Greeks).






            share|improve this answer














            According to Herodotus, "Stranger go tell..." is not the last words by a Spartan, but the inscription on the monument which was installed after the battle. (Book VII, 228). It is clear that Herodotus could see this monument.



            Concerning other details, the battle happened during the life time of Herodotus, though he was very young. So he could interview the survivors, or people who knew the survivors, and also people who fought on the Persian side (many of them were Greeks).







            share|improve this answer














            share|improve this answer



            share|improve this answer








            edited 9 hours ago

























            answered 9 hours ago









            Alex

            26k14897




            26k14897








            • 1




              "…if entire rear guard died…" – so, how did Herodotus interview 'survivors'?
              – LangLangC
              8 hours ago






            • 1




              @LangLangC - Well...presumably there were lots of survivors on the Persian side. Also, it wasn't just the famous "300" in the rearguard, and while the force was wiped out, presumably some prisoners were taken too (it would have been a military imperitive to do so just for the intelligence value). Personally I'm skeptical he ever "interviewed" anyone with first-hand knowledge, but it would have been possible.
              – T.E.D.
              8 hours ago








            • 1




              @T.E.D. Sure. But neither is that explicit in the A, quite counter-intuitively in fact. Nor/And then there are likely observers around, contrary to 300 cinematography, and not all Greek-side fighters died (Thespians, Athenians; where was Ephialtes? etc.). The plus-side an this A is the focus on the Monument. The minus is lack of specifics to what is known. "Survivors", when, where, who, under what conditions reported what (even conjecture based on known reports).
              – LangLangC
              7 hours ago














            • 1




              "…if entire rear guard died…" – so, how did Herodotus interview 'survivors'?
              – LangLangC
              8 hours ago






            • 1




              @LangLangC - Well...presumably there were lots of survivors on the Persian side. Also, it wasn't just the famous "300" in the rearguard, and while the force was wiped out, presumably some prisoners were taken too (it would have been a military imperitive to do so just for the intelligence value). Personally I'm skeptical he ever "interviewed" anyone with first-hand knowledge, but it would have been possible.
              – T.E.D.
              8 hours ago








            • 1




              @T.E.D. Sure. But neither is that explicit in the A, quite counter-intuitively in fact. Nor/And then there are likely observers around, contrary to 300 cinematography, and not all Greek-side fighters died (Thespians, Athenians; where was Ephialtes? etc.). The plus-side an this A is the focus on the Monument. The minus is lack of specifics to what is known. "Survivors", when, where, who, under what conditions reported what (even conjecture based on known reports).
              – LangLangC
              7 hours ago








            1




            1




            "…if entire rear guard died…" – so, how did Herodotus interview 'survivors'?
            – LangLangC
            8 hours ago




            "…if entire rear guard died…" – so, how did Herodotus interview 'survivors'?
            – LangLangC
            8 hours ago




            1




            1




            @LangLangC - Well...presumably there were lots of survivors on the Persian side. Also, it wasn't just the famous "300" in the rearguard, and while the force was wiped out, presumably some prisoners were taken too (it would have been a military imperitive to do so just for the intelligence value). Personally I'm skeptical he ever "interviewed" anyone with first-hand knowledge, but it would have been possible.
            – T.E.D.
            8 hours ago






            @LangLangC - Well...presumably there were lots of survivors on the Persian side. Also, it wasn't just the famous "300" in the rearguard, and while the force was wiped out, presumably some prisoners were taken too (it would have been a military imperitive to do so just for the intelligence value). Personally I'm skeptical he ever "interviewed" anyone with first-hand knowledge, but it would have been possible.
            – T.E.D.
            8 hours ago






            1




            1




            @T.E.D. Sure. But neither is that explicit in the A, quite counter-intuitively in fact. Nor/And then there are likely observers around, contrary to 300 cinematography, and not all Greek-side fighters died (Thespians, Athenians; where was Ephialtes? etc.). The plus-side an this A is the focus on the Monument. The minus is lack of specifics to what is known. "Survivors", when, where, who, under what conditions reported what (even conjecture based on known reports).
            – LangLangC
            7 hours ago




            @T.E.D. Sure. But neither is that explicit in the A, quite counter-intuitively in fact. Nor/And then there are likely observers around, contrary to 300 cinematography, and not all Greek-side fighters died (Thespians, Athenians; where was Ephialtes? etc.). The plus-side an this A is the focus on the Monument. The minus is lack of specifics to what is known. "Survivors", when, where, who, under what conditions reported what (even conjecture based on known reports).
            – LangLangC
            7 hours ago


















            draft saved

            draft discarded




















































            Thanks for contributing an answer to History Stack Exchange!


            • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

            But avoid



            • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

            • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


            To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.





            Some of your past answers have not been well-received, and you're in danger of being blocked from answering.


            Please pay close attention to the following guidance:


            • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

            But avoid



            • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

            • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


            To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




            draft saved


            draft discarded














            StackExchange.ready(
            function () {
            StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fhistory.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f49800%2fhow-was-herodotus-able-to-get-accounts-of-the-battle-of-thermopylae%23new-answer', 'question_page');
            }
            );

            Post as a guest















            Required, but never shown





















































            Required, but never shown














            Required, but never shown












            Required, but never shown







            Required, but never shown

































            Required, but never shown














            Required, but never shown












            Required, but never shown







            Required, but never shown







            Popular posts from this blog

            數位音樂下載

            When can things happen in Etherscan, such as the picture below?

            格利澤436b