Did the prefects sit separately?
.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty{ margin-bottom:0;
}
up vote
1
down vote
favorite
In Chapter Twelve of Philosopher's Stone the following sentence appears:
"And you're not sitting with the prefects today, either," said George. "Christmas is a time for family."
It appears from this sentence that the rest of the year (i.e. besides Christmas) the prefects sit separately from other students. I am trying to figure out what this is referring to.
I know that there is a special prefect carriage on the Hogwarts Express. From Philosopher's Stone Chapter Six:
"Can't stay long, Mother," he said. "I'm up front, the prefects have got two compartments to themselves —"
And from Order of the Phoenix Chapter Ten:
"We’re — well — Ron and I are supposed to go into the prefect carriage,” Hermione said awkwardly.
And from Half-Blood Prince Chapter Seven:
"We can't, Harry," said Hermione, looking apologetic. "Ron and I've got to go to the prefects' carriage first and then patrol the corridors for a bit.
However, George is clearly not referring to the Hogwarts Express. They don't go on the Hogwarts Express that day, and they have not been on it for nearly four months at this point. George is obviously referring to some more recent occurrences of Percy sitting with the prefects as opposed to his family.
I also know that there is a prefect bathroom. From Goblet of Fire Chapter Twenty-Three:
"Tell you what," Cedric said, "use the prefects' bathroom.
And from Half-Blood Prince Chapter Six:
"That gives you equal status with prefects!" cried Hermione happily. "You can use our special bathroom now and everything!"
But it is also pretty clear that George is not talking about which bathroom Percy uses.
So what is he talking about? What else is there where prefects sit separately from other students? I would have assumed that it might be referring to sitting in the common room, or sitting in the Great Hall, but as far as I know there is never mention of a special seating area for prefects in either of those locations. And if we are to assume that it means that the prefects simply unofficially sat together, there are other occasions where we see Percy sitting with the others both in the Great Hall, and in the common room. From Philosopher's Stone Chapter Seven:
On Harry's other side, Percy Weasley and Hermione were talking about lessons
From Chamber of Secrets Chapter Nine:
Harry, Ron, and Hermione chose seats as far as possible in the common room that night.
(Implying that otherwise, prefects and regular students sat intermixed.)
From Chamber of Secrets Chapter Fourteen:
Percy Weasley was sitting in a chair behind Lee, but for once he didn't seem keen to make his views heard. He was looking pale and stunned.
From Chamber of Secrets Chapter Sixteen:
"If you've finished eating, I'll take that seat, Ginny. I'm starving, I've only just come off patrol duty."
Ginny jumped up as though her chair had just been electrified, gave Percy a fleeting, frightened look, and scampered away.
From Prisoner of Azkaban Chapter Eleven:
Ron and Hermione watched Harry nervously all through dinner, not daring to talk about what they'd overheard, because Percy was sitting close by them.
And, of course, once Ron and Hermione became prefects they continued to always sit with Harry in the Great Hall and the common room.
So what phenomenon involving Percy sitting with the prefects was George referring to?
harry-potter
add a comment |
up vote
1
down vote
favorite
In Chapter Twelve of Philosopher's Stone the following sentence appears:
"And you're not sitting with the prefects today, either," said George. "Christmas is a time for family."
It appears from this sentence that the rest of the year (i.e. besides Christmas) the prefects sit separately from other students. I am trying to figure out what this is referring to.
I know that there is a special prefect carriage on the Hogwarts Express. From Philosopher's Stone Chapter Six:
"Can't stay long, Mother," he said. "I'm up front, the prefects have got two compartments to themselves —"
And from Order of the Phoenix Chapter Ten:
"We’re — well — Ron and I are supposed to go into the prefect carriage,” Hermione said awkwardly.
And from Half-Blood Prince Chapter Seven:
"We can't, Harry," said Hermione, looking apologetic. "Ron and I've got to go to the prefects' carriage first and then patrol the corridors for a bit.
However, George is clearly not referring to the Hogwarts Express. They don't go on the Hogwarts Express that day, and they have not been on it for nearly four months at this point. George is obviously referring to some more recent occurrences of Percy sitting with the prefects as opposed to his family.
I also know that there is a prefect bathroom. From Goblet of Fire Chapter Twenty-Three:
"Tell you what," Cedric said, "use the prefects' bathroom.
And from Half-Blood Prince Chapter Six:
"That gives you equal status with prefects!" cried Hermione happily. "You can use our special bathroom now and everything!"
But it is also pretty clear that George is not talking about which bathroom Percy uses.
So what is he talking about? What else is there where prefects sit separately from other students? I would have assumed that it might be referring to sitting in the common room, or sitting in the Great Hall, but as far as I know there is never mention of a special seating area for prefects in either of those locations. And if we are to assume that it means that the prefects simply unofficially sat together, there are other occasions where we see Percy sitting with the others both in the Great Hall, and in the common room. From Philosopher's Stone Chapter Seven:
On Harry's other side, Percy Weasley and Hermione were talking about lessons
From Chamber of Secrets Chapter Nine:
Harry, Ron, and Hermione chose seats as far as possible in the common room that night.
(Implying that otherwise, prefects and regular students sat intermixed.)
From Chamber of Secrets Chapter Fourteen:
Percy Weasley was sitting in a chair behind Lee, but for once he didn't seem keen to make his views heard. He was looking pale and stunned.
From Chamber of Secrets Chapter Sixteen:
"If you've finished eating, I'll take that seat, Ginny. I'm starving, I've only just come off patrol duty."
Ginny jumped up as though her chair had just been electrified, gave Percy a fleeting, frightened look, and scampered away.
From Prisoner of Azkaban Chapter Eleven:
Ron and Hermione watched Harry nervously all through dinner, not daring to talk about what they'd overheard, because Percy was sitting close by them.
And, of course, once Ron and Hermione became prefects they continued to always sit with Harry in the Great Hall and the common room.
So what phenomenon involving Percy sitting with the prefects was George referring to?
harry-potter
1
You've pretty much answered your own question, haven't you? "And you're not sitting with the prefects today, either," said George. "Christmas is a time for family." Logically, George wouldn't say that unless Percy often/frequently/usually sat with the other prefects. He may not have eaten with them all the time, but he must have eaten with them frequently enough to prompt George to warn him against it. Just because we didn't see/read it, doesn't mean it didn't happen. After all, we know there are toilets, but Nobody Poops...
– miltonaut
1 hour ago
add a comment |
up vote
1
down vote
favorite
up vote
1
down vote
favorite
In Chapter Twelve of Philosopher's Stone the following sentence appears:
"And you're not sitting with the prefects today, either," said George. "Christmas is a time for family."
It appears from this sentence that the rest of the year (i.e. besides Christmas) the prefects sit separately from other students. I am trying to figure out what this is referring to.
I know that there is a special prefect carriage on the Hogwarts Express. From Philosopher's Stone Chapter Six:
"Can't stay long, Mother," he said. "I'm up front, the prefects have got two compartments to themselves —"
And from Order of the Phoenix Chapter Ten:
"We’re — well — Ron and I are supposed to go into the prefect carriage,” Hermione said awkwardly.
And from Half-Blood Prince Chapter Seven:
"We can't, Harry," said Hermione, looking apologetic. "Ron and I've got to go to the prefects' carriage first and then patrol the corridors for a bit.
However, George is clearly not referring to the Hogwarts Express. They don't go on the Hogwarts Express that day, and they have not been on it for nearly four months at this point. George is obviously referring to some more recent occurrences of Percy sitting with the prefects as opposed to his family.
I also know that there is a prefect bathroom. From Goblet of Fire Chapter Twenty-Three:
"Tell you what," Cedric said, "use the prefects' bathroom.
And from Half-Blood Prince Chapter Six:
"That gives you equal status with prefects!" cried Hermione happily. "You can use our special bathroom now and everything!"
But it is also pretty clear that George is not talking about which bathroom Percy uses.
So what is he talking about? What else is there where prefects sit separately from other students? I would have assumed that it might be referring to sitting in the common room, or sitting in the Great Hall, but as far as I know there is never mention of a special seating area for prefects in either of those locations. And if we are to assume that it means that the prefects simply unofficially sat together, there are other occasions where we see Percy sitting with the others both in the Great Hall, and in the common room. From Philosopher's Stone Chapter Seven:
On Harry's other side, Percy Weasley and Hermione were talking about lessons
From Chamber of Secrets Chapter Nine:
Harry, Ron, and Hermione chose seats as far as possible in the common room that night.
(Implying that otherwise, prefects and regular students sat intermixed.)
From Chamber of Secrets Chapter Fourteen:
Percy Weasley was sitting in a chair behind Lee, but for once he didn't seem keen to make his views heard. He was looking pale and stunned.
From Chamber of Secrets Chapter Sixteen:
"If you've finished eating, I'll take that seat, Ginny. I'm starving, I've only just come off patrol duty."
Ginny jumped up as though her chair had just been electrified, gave Percy a fleeting, frightened look, and scampered away.
From Prisoner of Azkaban Chapter Eleven:
Ron and Hermione watched Harry nervously all through dinner, not daring to talk about what they'd overheard, because Percy was sitting close by them.
And, of course, once Ron and Hermione became prefects they continued to always sit with Harry in the Great Hall and the common room.
So what phenomenon involving Percy sitting with the prefects was George referring to?
harry-potter
In Chapter Twelve of Philosopher's Stone the following sentence appears:
"And you're not sitting with the prefects today, either," said George. "Christmas is a time for family."
It appears from this sentence that the rest of the year (i.e. besides Christmas) the prefects sit separately from other students. I am trying to figure out what this is referring to.
I know that there is a special prefect carriage on the Hogwarts Express. From Philosopher's Stone Chapter Six:
"Can't stay long, Mother," he said. "I'm up front, the prefects have got two compartments to themselves —"
And from Order of the Phoenix Chapter Ten:
"We’re — well — Ron and I are supposed to go into the prefect carriage,” Hermione said awkwardly.
And from Half-Blood Prince Chapter Seven:
"We can't, Harry," said Hermione, looking apologetic. "Ron and I've got to go to the prefects' carriage first and then patrol the corridors for a bit.
However, George is clearly not referring to the Hogwarts Express. They don't go on the Hogwarts Express that day, and they have not been on it for nearly four months at this point. George is obviously referring to some more recent occurrences of Percy sitting with the prefects as opposed to his family.
I also know that there is a prefect bathroom. From Goblet of Fire Chapter Twenty-Three:
"Tell you what," Cedric said, "use the prefects' bathroom.
And from Half-Blood Prince Chapter Six:
"That gives you equal status with prefects!" cried Hermione happily. "You can use our special bathroom now and everything!"
But it is also pretty clear that George is not talking about which bathroom Percy uses.
So what is he talking about? What else is there where prefects sit separately from other students? I would have assumed that it might be referring to sitting in the common room, or sitting in the Great Hall, but as far as I know there is never mention of a special seating area for prefects in either of those locations. And if we are to assume that it means that the prefects simply unofficially sat together, there are other occasions where we see Percy sitting with the others both in the Great Hall, and in the common room. From Philosopher's Stone Chapter Seven:
On Harry's other side, Percy Weasley and Hermione were talking about lessons
From Chamber of Secrets Chapter Nine:
Harry, Ron, and Hermione chose seats as far as possible in the common room that night.
(Implying that otherwise, prefects and regular students sat intermixed.)
From Chamber of Secrets Chapter Fourteen:
Percy Weasley was sitting in a chair behind Lee, but for once he didn't seem keen to make his views heard. He was looking pale and stunned.
From Chamber of Secrets Chapter Sixteen:
"If you've finished eating, I'll take that seat, Ginny. I'm starving, I've only just come off patrol duty."
Ginny jumped up as though her chair had just been electrified, gave Percy a fleeting, frightened look, and scampered away.
From Prisoner of Azkaban Chapter Eleven:
Ron and Hermione watched Harry nervously all through dinner, not daring to talk about what they'd overheard, because Percy was sitting close by them.
And, of course, once Ron and Hermione became prefects they continued to always sit with Harry in the Great Hall and the common room.
So what phenomenon involving Percy sitting with the prefects was George referring to?
harry-potter
harry-potter
asked 5 hours ago
Alex
11.3k12963
11.3k12963
1
You've pretty much answered your own question, haven't you? "And you're not sitting with the prefects today, either," said George. "Christmas is a time for family." Logically, George wouldn't say that unless Percy often/frequently/usually sat with the other prefects. He may not have eaten with them all the time, but he must have eaten with them frequently enough to prompt George to warn him against it. Just because we didn't see/read it, doesn't mean it didn't happen. After all, we know there are toilets, but Nobody Poops...
– miltonaut
1 hour ago
add a comment |
1
You've pretty much answered your own question, haven't you? "And you're not sitting with the prefects today, either," said George. "Christmas is a time for family." Logically, George wouldn't say that unless Percy often/frequently/usually sat with the other prefects. He may not have eaten with them all the time, but he must have eaten with them frequently enough to prompt George to warn him against it. Just because we didn't see/read it, doesn't mean it didn't happen. After all, we know there are toilets, but Nobody Poops...
– miltonaut
1 hour ago
1
1
You've pretty much answered your own question, haven't you? "And you're not sitting with the prefects today, either," said George. "Christmas is a time for family." Logically, George wouldn't say that unless Percy often/frequently/usually sat with the other prefects. He may not have eaten with them all the time, but he must have eaten with them frequently enough to prompt George to warn him against it. Just because we didn't see/read it, doesn't mean it didn't happen. After all, we know there are toilets, but Nobody Poops...
– miltonaut
1 hour ago
You've pretty much answered your own question, haven't you? "And you're not sitting with the prefects today, either," said George. "Christmas is a time for family." Logically, George wouldn't say that unless Percy often/frequently/usually sat with the other prefects. He may not have eaten with them all the time, but he must have eaten with them frequently enough to prompt George to warn him against it. Just because we didn't see/read it, doesn't mean it didn't happen. After all, we know there are toilets, but Nobody Poops...
– miltonaut
1 hour ago
add a comment |
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
up vote
4
down vote
George is talking about Christmas dinner.
The house prefects would normally all sit together at regular mealtimes throughout the year, so George is telling Percy that he should sit with family and not friends for Christmas.
Do you have a reference that this is true?
– Alex
5 hours ago
Other than this is how things would normally work in a British private school, which is what Rowling modelled Hogwarts on
– HorusKol
4 hours ago
add a comment |
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
4
down vote
George is talking about Christmas dinner.
The house prefects would normally all sit together at regular mealtimes throughout the year, so George is telling Percy that he should sit with family and not friends for Christmas.
Do you have a reference that this is true?
– Alex
5 hours ago
Other than this is how things would normally work in a British private school, which is what Rowling modelled Hogwarts on
– HorusKol
4 hours ago
add a comment |
up vote
4
down vote
George is talking about Christmas dinner.
The house prefects would normally all sit together at regular mealtimes throughout the year, so George is telling Percy that he should sit with family and not friends for Christmas.
Do you have a reference that this is true?
– Alex
5 hours ago
Other than this is how things would normally work in a British private school, which is what Rowling modelled Hogwarts on
– HorusKol
4 hours ago
add a comment |
up vote
4
down vote
up vote
4
down vote
George is talking about Christmas dinner.
The house prefects would normally all sit together at regular mealtimes throughout the year, so George is telling Percy that he should sit with family and not friends for Christmas.
George is talking about Christmas dinner.
The house prefects would normally all sit together at regular mealtimes throughout the year, so George is telling Percy that he should sit with family and not friends for Christmas.
answered 5 hours ago
HorusKol
32k3107161
32k3107161
Do you have a reference that this is true?
– Alex
5 hours ago
Other than this is how things would normally work in a British private school, which is what Rowling modelled Hogwarts on
– HorusKol
4 hours ago
add a comment |
Do you have a reference that this is true?
– Alex
5 hours ago
Other than this is how things would normally work in a British private school, which is what Rowling modelled Hogwarts on
– HorusKol
4 hours ago
Do you have a reference that this is true?
– Alex
5 hours ago
Do you have a reference that this is true?
– Alex
5 hours ago
Other than this is how things would normally work in a British private school, which is what Rowling modelled Hogwarts on
– HorusKol
4 hours ago
Other than this is how things would normally work in a British private school, which is what Rowling modelled Hogwarts on
– HorusKol
4 hours ago
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Some of your past answers have not been well-received, and you're in danger of being blocked from answering.
Please pay close attention to the following guidance:
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f199689%2fdid-the-prefects-sit-separately%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
1
You've pretty much answered your own question, haven't you? "And you're not sitting with the prefects today, either," said George. "Christmas is a time for family." Logically, George wouldn't say that unless Percy often/frequently/usually sat with the other prefects. He may not have eaten with them all the time, but he must have eaten with them frequently enough to prompt George to warn him against it. Just because we didn't see/read it, doesn't mean it didn't happen. After all, we know there are toilets, but Nobody Poops...
– miltonaut
1 hour ago